News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by delecti on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:39AM (#34427996)
> how in the world humanity survived to this point

By outbreeding the fact that we also died a bunch for unknown reasons.

And I think this tweet is actually a fairly calming view on things. I wouldn't hesitate to share a room with a couple extra people, so I won't worry about a few candles occasionally, because they're a nice benefit to the space. Meanwhile it's an absolute no-brainer (for me and many other people) to avoid gas stoves, because they don't have any ambience benefits and my local power grid is quite stable.

Living in bubbles might be biologically safer, but we're also creatures that need to live, so it's not a tradeoff most people would (or should) accept. We can make gradual incremental change as we learn more though, and we should try to do so.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by Gordonjcp on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:42AM (#34428041)
> Meanwhile it's an absolute no-brainer (for me and many other people) to avoid gas stoves

Surely you mean avoiding dangerous electric stoves, which emit hazardous electromagnetic radiation?

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by delecti on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:38AM (#34429001)
Based on this [1] source, which is clearly biased against electric stoves, an electric heater (lets include a stove in that) "can generate over 100 milliGauss (mG)". The SI equivalent unit is the Tesla, with 1 Tesla being equal to 10,000 Gauss. So that 100 mG from the stove is equal to 10 microTesla. A fridge magnet is about 1 miliTesla [2], so just holding a fridge magnet is 100 times as much "harmful" radiation. It's absurd to think electric stoves are a concern.

[1] https://emfguardtips.com/do-electric-stoves-emit-emf/ [2] https://sciencing.com/strong-standard-magnet-6853786.html

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by kadoban on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:54AM (#34428268)
> Surely you mean avoiding dangerous electric stoves, which emit hazardous electromagnetic radiation?

The "electromagnetic radiation" from stoves has not been shown to be harmful in the amounts absorbed during cooking.

Particles in the air _have_ been shown to be harmful, even ignoring CO and gas leak risks from gas stoves.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by Gordonjcp on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:11PM (#34429530)
> even ignoring CO and gas leak risks from gas stoves

Right, but they don't generate CO and they don't leak. If they do, they are faulty and should be repaired or replaced.

Don't you have safety inspections where you are?

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by kadoban on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @04:18PM (#34433215)
> [...] they don't leak. If they do [...]
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by Gordonjcp on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:08AM (#34437530)
Not sure what your fairly illiterate point is, there.
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by fastball on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:49AM (#34428184)
Is non-ionizing radiation hazardous?
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by trashtester on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:18AM (#34428657)
it depends on the dose. Visible light from a nuke will kill you more quckly than the gamma rays if youre close enough.
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by sampo on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:02AM (#34428377)
> Is non-ionizing radiation hazardous?

At LTE and WiFi frequency bands, it can be used to spread a great deal of misinformation.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by Gordonjcp on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:10PM (#34429518)
Put your hand on the cooker ring and tell me.
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @02:23PM (#34431626)
You understand that if things touch each other the heat transfer isn't from radiation right?
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by Gordonjcp on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @03:42PM (#34432791)
You understand you've been utterly whooshed, right?
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by CyberDildonics on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @06:09PM (#34434436)
To be clear your joke is:

1. You don't understand something

2. Someone tells you that you don't understand

3. Got you good, can't believe you fell for my ignorance

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by Gordonjcp on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:43AM (#34442344)
It's like a party trick with you, isn't it?

Can you point out what you think I don't understand?

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by CyberDildonics on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:12PM (#34444293)
It's like a party trick with you, isn't it?

I don't know what this is supposed to mean.

Can you point out what you think I don't understand?

Electric stoves don't give off harmful radiation.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by Gordonjcp on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:58PM (#34444837)
> Electric stoves don't give off harmful radiation.

Yes, that's the joke. You got whooshed. Don't worry, it happens.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by CyberDildonics on Thursday January 19, 2023 @03:55PM (#34445479)
I guess this is the part where you reveal you were "just pretending"
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by musingsole on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:42AM (#34428044)
> By outbreeding the fact that we also died a bunch for unknown reasons.

You really do the robustness of the human body and immune system a disservice.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by kadoban on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:56AM (#34428303)
The human body and immune system is pretty good at, on average, keeping us living long enough to produce offspring and a bit after.

If you want any more than that, you should do what you can to help it along, including avoiding known harmful substances where you can.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by koolba on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @10:45AM (#34428112)
> Meanwhile it's an absolute no-brainer (for me and many other people) to avoid gas stoves, because they don't have any ambience benefits and my local power grid is quite stable.

Not sure about ambience, but pita bread heated directly on the flame of a gas stove cannot be beat. It’s faster and more delicious than any electric toaster.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by s17n on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:34AM (#34428934)
> We can make gradual incremental change as we learn more though, and we should try to do so.

We shouldn't thoughtlessly make gradual changes which sacrifice quality of life for safety (which is the direction that these changes always seem to go) without actually deciding that the benefits are worth the costs.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by delecti on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:42AM (#34429078)
Agreed, and that was my entire point. I think the tradeoffs for candles are worth it, I don't think the tradeoffs for gas stoves are worth it, and they probably aren't for quite a few people.
Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by s17n on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @09:29PM (#34436032)
I think the problem is that we don't have a great way of quantifying the impact, so the tradeoff always ends up being something like "people are literally going to die, is pleasant light worth human lives?"

The answer IMO is "yes, if the number of deaths is small enough relative to the total amount of pleasure that the pretty lights create", but without a quantitative framework it's pretty tough to make that call.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by tristor on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:14PM (#34429578)
> Meanwhile it's an absolute no-brainer (for me and many other people) to avoid gas stoves, because they don't have any ambience benefits and my local power grid is quite stable.

Except that all the concern around gas stoves is mostly BS. The issue with cooking is not the heat source, it's actually the fumes from cooking itself. The ONLY safe way to cook from an indoor air quality perspective is to have a properly installed externally vented range hood (and makeup air if needed). It doesn't matter if you use induction, radiant, or coil electric, they all produce just as much cooking fumes as gas, and the gas burning has a negligible impact. I've confirmed this myself many times over with calibrated sensors.

The worst thing about indoor air quality in the US is that the US doesn't require external venting in kitchens by code, and it should. The PM2.5 spikes in nearly every American household the moment someone starts cooking, and to dangerous levels for the person doing the cooking. American houses also have horrible ventilation generally, with newer houses being even worse as they get better sealed for efficiency, but without being required to provide active ventilation. It should be legally required that every home, including rental apartments, be constructed with an externally vented range hood and an energy recovery style active ventilation for fresh air exchange.

I challenge folks to improve their indoor air quality and see how much it benefits them by simply opening your windows up at least once a day (which unfortunately isn't the most energy efficient thing to do), and finding a way to actively ventilate your kitchen when you cook (if nothing better, a box fan in an open window is not a bad way to go. recirculating range hoods do nothing).

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by danans on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @12:56PM (#34430265)
> It doesn't matter if you use induction, radiant, or coil electric, they all produce just as much cooking fumes as gas, and the gas burning has a negligible impact.

> I've confirmed this myself many times over with calibrated sensors.

This really means nothing considering that rigorous studies and metastudies [1] have been performed and the results published that demonstrate the opposite: that gas stoves result in CO and other harmful emissions that electric stoves don't, independent of what is being cooked. Those studies aren't a global conspiracy against gas stoves. If you have similarly published your data and it has been reviewed, please do share it with the world.

> The worst thing about indoor air quality in the US is that the US doesn't require external venting in kitchens by code, and it should

I agree wholeheartedly, but the problem doesn't end there. Most range hoods in single family homes are externally vented, but there is a behavioral problem, which is that most people use the kitchen hood vent as a way to exhaust smoke odors only, usually only in response to a smoke alarm going off. Even worse, after enough rounds of this, many people end up disabling the smoke alarms near their kitchen rather than taking it as an indication that there is an air quality problem.

If the only effect of these studies is to alert people to the necessity of turning on their hood vent and opening a window for makeup air every time they cook, especially on a gas stove, that's a win.

1. https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/17/23/8972

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by tristor on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:34PM (#34430852)
> Most range hoods in single family homes are externally vented,

I wish this were true, unfortunately it's not. Most homes in the US, including freestanding SFHs, use recirculating range hoods.

> that gas stoves result in CO and other harmful emissions that electric stoves don't, independent of what is being cooked.

This is true. It's also a negligible difference, and mostly immaterial if you are externally venting fumes when using the stove. The biggest issue is not the carbon monoxide and other emissions, it's the particulate matter that is given off when cooking, which happens quickly during cooking and irrespective of heat sources. Consistently breathing in high levels of PM2.5 has severe health consequences, including increasing risk for lung diseases and cancer, even when the particulates themselves are not carcinogenic. What's worse, many particulates given off when cooking /are/ carcinogenic, such as when searing meats.

Ventilation is the most critical aspect here. There are more important safety reasons why people should avoid open flames and direct heat in favor of electric induction, as well as environmental reasons as all-electric homes can be powered using exclusively renewable energy sources, these are much better arguments against using a gas stove than the air emissions, which are insignificant compared to cooking fumes themselves and both need resolved via ventilation.

> there is a behavioral problem, which is that most people use the kitchen hood vent as a way to exhaust smoke odors only

Agreed. One of the challenges in the US is that because most range hoods are recirculating and not vented, especially in rental/cheaper properties, people become effectively trained to not use it because they are very loud and not effective. Externally vented range hoods are both quieter and are actually effective, and train people to use them once they're exposed to them.

> many people end up disabling the smoke alarms near their kitchen rather than taking it as an indication that there is an air quality problem.

This is a real issue, and a big issue for fire safety as well. Most American homes also don't have carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide monitoring, both of which are major issues. We also have significant exposure to radon in the US, and no state currently legally requires landlords to provide mitigation and testing for radon.

There are myriad indoor air quality issues in the US, and proper ventilation can solve or mitigate almost all of them, and when it's present it does not train bad habits and may untrain bad habits.

Re:John Carmack on candles, energy and air quality (tweet) by danans on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @02:20PM (#34431569)
> I wish this were true, unfortunately it's not. Most homes in the US, including freestanding SFHs, use recirculating range hoods.

We must have very different anecdotal sample populations of single family homes, because I've only ever seen the recirculating types in condos and apartments, where they are done that way due to space/ducting constraints. But there is very little data available on this question. The closest I found was in this study relating specifically to California:

"A survey-based study of 1448 detached houses built in 2003 reported that 80% had range hoods exhausting to outdoors and 4% had downdraft ventilators, while 13% had recirculating range hoods and 3% had no range hood or did not know [34]"

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7729668/

Those stats echo my own observations in two places: California and the Midwest. But it's possible that it's completely reversed in other places. Building codes can vary a lot, after all.

I completely believe that recirculating fans are more prevalent in low-income resident properties, though. That's also something I've seen extensively.

> Externally vented range hoods are both quieter and are actually effective, and train people to use them once they're exposed to them.

People are really bad at diligently doing inconvenient things, even if it means an improvement in their health. My dentist is always on my case about flossing more, but I end up starting up a week or two before my cleaning. Also, we are bad at evaluating invisible or quotidian risks, which is why many have an incorrect understanding of the risks of flying vs driving.

The long term solution to this problem is to require automatic makeup air ventilation systems for all kitchens in the codes, but that will probably be a long pull. As for indoor gas stoves, I imagine with time they will have the same trajectory as ICE cars. Remember that gas stoves were once the novel high tech replacement for wood and coal stoves, and also on the basis of the improved health and convenience, just as induction is today.