Re:Knots to Narnia – Bill Thurston (1992) [video]
by robinhouston on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @02:33PM
(#34431788)
This is a lovely lecture by the legendary topologist Bill Thurston, in which he illustrates the cyclic branched cover of a knot by interpreting the knot as a portal to other universes.
I don’t think the idea has ever been used in a real video game, but there have been a few demos: the most impressive is the VR demo [0], which is described in detail with lots of background in [1].
There’s also a pretty comprehensive thread on Twitter where @RAnachro collects a lot of videos and demos of knotted portals.
Re:Knots to Narnia – Bill Thurston (1992) [video]
by NateEag on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:04PM
(#34436564)
I think only at the level that in the books Narnia is reached from our world via magical portals, so it's a reasonable reference to make when discussing portals.
Re:Knots to Narnia – Bill Thurston (1992) [video]
by nhatcher on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @08:20PM
(#34435543)
Thurston was very active on mathoverflow snd a lovely character. His answer on "What's a mathematitian to do?" [1] is fairly famous by now. It's been already on HN a couple of times [2]
His geometrization conjecture is at the backbone of Perelman's proof of Poincaré hypothesis.
Re:Knots to Narnia – Bill Thurston (1992) [video]
by raldi on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:45AM
(#34437114)
I understand how going through a portal (let's say an un-knot to keep it simple) and then back through it in the opposite direction takes you back where you came from; it's like passing a piece of string through a ring and then back out the inside again, the ring falls off.
But what I don't understand is how going through a portal, then back around the outside and through it again, takes you to the same place. If you run a string through a ring, then around the outside and back through the middle again in the same direction, the ring is stuck on the string.
I don’t think the idea has ever been used in a real video game, but there have been a few demos: the most impressive is the VR demo [0], which is described in detail with lots of background in [1].
There’s also a pretty comprehensive thread on Twitter where @RAnachro collects a lot of videos and demos of knotted portals.
[0] https://www.imaginary.org/program/knotportal
[1] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00283-020-10028-8
[2] https://twitter.com/RAnachro/status/1362478176874754050
[1] https://mathoverflow.net/questions/43690/whats-a-mathematici... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23461983
But what I don't understand is how going through a portal, then back around the outside and through it again, takes you to the same place. If you run a string through a ring, then around the outside and back through the middle again in the same direction, the ring is stuck on the string.
There are other possibilities. For example, in https://youtu.be/eb2DhCcGH7U you have to go round _three_ times to get back to where you started.