Re:Ask HN: Please critique my crowd-sourced patent debunking...
by Samuel_Michon on Monday January 09, 2012 @12:27AM
(#3441543)
"is this something you'd actually participate to as a player? Does this sound fun?"
Yes, and yes!
However, I really hope you have a solid grasp of the IP laws in different locales, and what "prior art" means in those locales. I don't and I suspect many HNers don't either. For instance, I often read on HN that the iPad isn't innovative, because it resembles the PADD communicator from Star Trek, calling that "prior art". I don't know, maybe it is. Maybe I can design a flying saucer, and I won't be able to patent it because hundreds of Sci-Fi movies provide prior art.
Yes, and yes!
However, I really hope you have a solid grasp of the IP laws in different locales, and what "prior art" means in those locales. I don't and I suspect many HNers don't either. For instance, I often read on HN that the iPad isn't innovative, because it resembles the PADD communicator from Star Trek, calling that "prior art". I don't know, maybe it is. Maybe I can design a flying saucer, and I won't be able to patent it because hundreds of Sci-Fi movies provide prior art.