News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by itslennysfault on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:29AM (#34414550)
Honestly, I'm surprised by "follow the river" as a flight instruction. That sounds like the directions you'd get from someone that doesn't understand cardinal directions. "Turn right at the gas station, then turn left at the big oak tree" or something.

I have no experience with flying, but I assumed it would be a heading / cardinal direction and not "turn right at [landmark]"

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by throw827474737 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:41AM (#34414730)
Hmm, can someone just paint me that path into Google Maps?

Washington National has no 18, but only a 19, and I guess everyone takes off southwards as directly north is the White House? Also the river is like parallel to the runway, an follow the river there is super clear, no turn needed?

I must be looking at the wrong airport?

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by tylermw on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:46AM (#34414817)
Many planes take off northwards, and immediately bank to follow the river.

Famously, see:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Florida_Flight_90

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by snowwrestler on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:49AM (#34414861)
When planes take off northbound from National, they immediately bank left (northwest) to remain over the river and avoid the exclusion zones in DC.

Conversely, planes landing southbound follow the river and so are banking to the right until a few seconds before touching down.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by cowsup on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:52AM (#34414901)
You’re correct. I live near DC and travel there for photography (much like the novice pilot in the OP).

If you’re flying near DC, or anywhere really, you should at least have a broad understanding of where you cannot fly. That is your responsibility; nobody in your ear will say “remember, don’t go to the restricted airspace.”

The pilot never claims to be the victim here, either. They screwed up and learned their lesson.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by wolrah on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:06PM (#34415119)
> Washington National has no 18, but only a 19

Depending on how long ago this happened that could be the same runway. There was an article that made the front page here in the last month or so about how the movement of the magnetic poles requires runway names to be adjusted periodically. This isn't that same article, I didn't feel like digging through my history, but it explains the same topic.

https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/news/airport-runway-names-shift-ma...

Agreed on the rest though, I just can't figure out a path that makes this story make sense.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by etothepii on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:48PM (#34415796)
Indeed but CGPGrey explains it in excruciating detail on YouTube. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qD6bPNZRRbQ
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:21PM (#34423401)
I always find it funny how shortly after CGPGrey posts about a thing (or John Oliver does a segment on LWT), a large number of commenters will speak on it as experts at the next available opportunity. It's obvious how many of us watch the same channels.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by throw827474737 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @05:37AM (#34425259)
Thanks for all and that link, but yeah I was assuming 18==19 already and meant to understand runway numbers, maybe should have left out that detail.

Actual question still sticks: Takeoff on 18 southwards basically makes you follow the river immediately. Where did this guy encounter his left/right decision, to get back towards white house? he must have made almost a uturn then?

And even assuming the article is a bit inaccurate and he took of northwards (thanks for pointing out the patterns pilots have to fly if doing that @ others): I still cannot imagine how that plane flew and where it matches the description of: "When I reached 1500 feet I looked down. I was crossing the river. It went right and left."

???

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by dwater on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:52PM (#34417796)
I used to sit nearby on my lunch break, and on a clear day you could watch planes after takeoff clearly follow the course of the river N/NW until completely out of sight, which would probably have been close the DC/Maryland border. They would be going in and out every few minutes and they all took the exact same flight path.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by advisedwang on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:48AM (#34414841)
"follow the river" is more than a single turn; the river winds so it's a sequence of turns. Because of this saying follow the river is much more concise than the specific turns.

Many of the takeoff and landing patterns do follow the river: https://skyvector.com/airport/DCA/Ronald-Reagan-Washington-N...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by treis on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:55AM (#34414947)
It's fairly obvious when you look at the map:

https://www.google.com/maps/place/Ronald+Reagan+Washington+N...

Left is upstream and away from DC. Right is towards restricted airspace.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by jcrawfordor on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:12PM (#34415215)
This is a fairly common instruction from a controller in my experience, at least when dealing with small aircraft that they know are flying VFR. Traditional VFR navigation ("pilotage") is mostly based on finding landmarks anyway. Flying in another city with a runway pointed towards a river, "turn after the river," "report crossing the river" are common instructions.

Other landmarks popular with controllers include the freeway, the big Marriot, the Amazon warehouse, etc. It's sort of surprisingly informal when controllers are dealing with local light aircraft pilots. But that's mostly how those pilots are navigating anyway, "follow the freeway until the bridge."

There probably is a certain risk of misunderstanding here, but then pilots are expected to be reasonably familiar with the local area and its procedures, and to ask for vectors when unsure. These days DC is one of those places that it's strongly recommended (required by FARs now, I think?) to take a familiarization course because the airspace issues there are so sensitive. Plus they have the laser gun to minimize the need to send fighters.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by tjohns on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @04:16PM (#34419296)
Indeed. Popular landmarks used by ATC in the SF Bay Area include a sunken ship in the middle of the bay, a (particularly large) church, a community college, an AT&T telephone office, the KNBR antenna, and major freeways. Among others.

It's different when flying IFR, but pilotage is an important part of VFR navigation.

It's also worth noting there's an IFR visual approach plate for DCA that basically says the same thing - "follow the river":

RIVER VISUAL RWY 19 - https://www.fly.faa.gov/Information/east/zdc/dca/atcCharts/D...

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by quest88 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:54PM (#34421873)
Don't forget Embassy Suites! Ha.
Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by dbrueck on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:47PM (#34415790)
It's actually fairly common (in my area, for example, it's common for the controller to tell you to follow the interstate for awhile, and it works especially well at night).

Keep in mind too that just telling someone to fly a certain direction is insufficient - the controller is trying to maintain separation among aircraft, so they need you to follow a particular path through a volume.

Re:My grandfather was almost shot down by ground to air miss... by quest88 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:55PM (#34421892)
Nah it's pretty common. When I take people around the golden gate bridge ATC tells me "Remain west of the 101 / Keep the 101 off your right at or below 2,000". And then later "Remain north and west of bay bridge".