I still think there's something off about the power asymmetry though.
Which is to say, nothing prevents a company from offering that deal as an alternative, rather than attempting to force it through with a non-compete. But, the employee would have to consider the cost to them of basically pausing their career development and letting their skills atrophy. That’s a pretty big cost! It seems unfair to force that cost on them through the contract (especially if we agree with the premise that non-competes are usually entered on a sort of unwilling basis).
Nothing prevents the company from offering this sort of deal currently. But I’d expect something higher than the offer, to take it. Companies don’t seem to offer this sort of deal currently, I guess because it seems like a pretty bad deal on their side too. Paying somebody to do nothing seems pretty expensive, I think you only do that for political favors.
* not working due to noncompete and not getting paid for the duration of time
* not working due to noncompete and getting paid for the duration of time
The point is to make noncompetes a hassle and only worth it if you’re actually trying to protect something. The status quo is pretty poor if Subway’s “sandwich artists” are getting told to sign noncompetes without compensation. Companies aren’t really offering the latter if they don’t have to, because they’re more expensive; with the notable exception of finance.
The NYT has more examples including a summer camp counselor: https://archive.ph/1BvoM
If the noncompete truly has no value, and it is also not worth paying out for, then it should just not be in the employment contract to start.