A lot of managers feel the same way when engineers talk about tech debt, refactoring, etc. Maybe they've never read code, or aren't familiar with the specific codebase. Projects seem to be getting completed—what's the problem? Maybe velocity is going down, but are the engineers right about why? Or are they just being anal about something that's simply less than ideal?
A good contractor walks you through why the repair is needed, what your options are (cheap temporary fix, long-term repair, total replacement), the consequences of those choices, and how much each will cost.
Unfortunately in software we don't really know how to answer any of those questions. A lot of refactorings and rewrites just shuffle irreducible complexity around ("it makes so much more sense now!" says the developer who just spent a week studying the code and rearranging it to their personal preferences). Not to mention that we suck at giving estimates.
Good senior engineers can absolutely answer these questions. Is this not what you've seen in Enterprise software dev? I'd say if you're a senior engineer in this context it's more than half of your job.
This 100%. Technical debt is placeholder term for engineers who want to do stuff but don't want to spend time explaining the people paying their salaries why they are doing it. Technical debt is meaningless. Be more specific. Present options. Be a professional?
Mobile apps are pretty high maintenance because you often have to change something with new OS releases and want to roll out an update. You can abstract over the platform but that is in itself costly, so there is a tradeoff.
If the painters/electricians also lived in the house, and it was their only/primary shelter, the 'owner' isn't the only one 'best qualified' to make maintenance decisions.
Traditional workers have the job market as backup.
The incentives do not align.
Tech debt and house repairs are the same.
Plumbers, electricians, roofers, painters and the like will all encourage you to handle your repairs timely and proactively do maintenance.
But in the end, it’s the owner (shareholders) of the home that is best qualified to make maintenance decisions based on their needs, wants and resources.
We as developers are service professionals (contractors) and it’s not unless you also have equity that you will have a better sense of how to handle tech debt appropriately.
Bring on the downvotes :p