Re:Lawsuit challenging Stable Diffusion filed against Devian...
by miohtama on Saturday January 14, 2023 @09:48AM
(#34380692)
People in art school also practice by studying existing art and images.
Re:Lawsuit challenging Stable Diffusion filed against Devian...
by thethimble on Saturday January 14, 2023 @09:53AM
(#34380721)
I think what’s clear is that this is an unprecedented type of use. I’m really interested in seeing how the courts rule on this one as it has wide implications for the AI era.
Re:Lawsuit challenging Stable Diffusion filed against Devian...
by speleding on Saturday January 14, 2023 @10:02AM
(#34380792)
Because this use is unprecedented, as you say, it's clear that the law wasn't written with this use case in mind. The more interesting question in my mind is what we think the new law should be, rather than what the courts happen to make of the existing law. I.e., I think the answer should come from politicians not from judges.
Re:Lawsuit challenging Stable Diffusion filed against Devian...
by joshspankit on Saturday January 14, 2023 @09:56AM
(#34380750)
If not done extremely carefully, it also has wide implications for human artists
Discovery will show exactly what the base images for training are. You can view that the outputs are derivative works.
I don't think the mechanism is going to shield the violation, and frankly it shouldn't.
License your source material for the purpose and do it right. Doesn't everyone know it's wrong to steal?