News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by 0ct4via on Saturday January 14, 2023 @08:51AM (#34380316)
Non-technical end users won't want to be trying to enter Terminal commands they don't know or understand, and they shouldn't have to.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by vbezhenar on Saturday January 14, 2023 @10:37AM (#34381081)
How is it different from running shell scripts they don't understand (or entire applications for that matter)?
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by einherjae on Saturday January 14, 2023 @10:47AM (#34381162)
It’s scarier, less ergonomic, and smells hacker-y.

There is a significant difference between “just click on this”, and “open the DOS prompt and write these magical runes”

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by vbezhenar on Saturday January 14, 2023 @11:26AM (#34381474)
It was observed that people get attached to Ikea furniture because they assembled it and it contains tiny bit of their labour.

May be it could work with software? Like you've executed some scary command to enable this software to work, now you attached to it.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by 0ct4via on Saturday January 14, 2023 @11:58AM (#34381732)
That's not a fair comparison though -- if you screwdriver slips or you put the wrong screw in the hole, your sofa doesn't stop working -- but you could do real damage to your OS.

IKEA furniture assembly involves very simple tasks and tools, and a guide that's purely pictorial -- and even then, there are an array of services where people will do that assembly for you, even offerings from IKEA themselves.

Software neither has the same physical presence, nor the same relative lack of risk. The average person can appreciate something "made with their own hands," but lacks the specialist knowledge to appreciate a script or code deployment.

Given how scared and how easily-scammed people can be by having someone open Event Viewer in Windows and claim this means their computer has viruses, opening some script and demanding verbatim typing of commands is more likely to lead to anxiety or unsureness than anything, and certainly not attachment.

You're thinking as if the average person is the average HN reader -- they're not. At all.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by Someone on Saturday January 14, 2023 @11:46AM (#34381618)
You mean that both are scary/require you to trust the person telling you to do it, but only the shell script also looks scary?
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by einherjae on Saturday January 14, 2023 @04:43PM (#34384454)
The shell script is abstracted, and can hide a lot of the ugliness to the average user, whereas “type this into your terminal” goes full arcane black magic to the average user. But any opening of a terminal means we’re not in Kansas any more, and can’t be relied upon for any average user flow.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by samoit on Saturday January 14, 2023 @11:08AM (#34381331)
Then, these users maybe should be using ios and not macos
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by 0ct4via on Saturday January 14, 2023 @12:10PM (#34381839)
How do you work that one out?

The average user shouldn't need to delve into the command line -- whether it's macOS, Windows, Ubuntu (for example), whatever -- that's the whole point of a GUI.

System Software (later Mac OS, for Mac OS 7.6 through Mac OS 9) didn't have a command line interface available. That did Apple pretty well from 1984 to 2001.

Mac OS X (and later OS X, then macOS) obviously have the Terminal app, but it is neither a requirement nor in common usage for the average desktop user.

Maybe don't be so classist and reductive? Not everyone hangs out on HN and uses terminal emulators regularly...

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by bookofjoe on Saturday January 14, 2023 @12:45PM (#34382137)
I've been hanging out on and enjoying HN daily for many years and I STILL have NO IDEA what a Terminal app or command line is — nor will I ever try to find out.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by 0ct4via on Sunday January 15, 2023 @11:21AM (#34390529)
That's perfectly ok -- it's saddening when there are demeaning comments like above -- it's elitist and exclusionary.

You keep doing what you're doing -- I'm pleased to have encountered the world's most popular blogging anesthesiologist!

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by bookofjoe on Sunday January 15, 2023 @01:58PM (#34391984)
38 years of passing gas was enough.