Re:Programming Interviews Turn Normal People into A-Holes
by throwgoof on Friday January 13, 2023 @07:28PM
(#34375880)
Sounds like you're huffing your own farts, to be frank.
You really can't tell anything at all from a conversational interview besides: can this person hold a conversation? And minor inklings of whether or not the person is insane.
But otherwise, people lie, and misconstrue, and misrepresent, and plan beforehand. The only thing these conversations are going to do is confirm your own biases.
I'm more inclined to believe whoever set up your hiring pipeline did the majority of the work, and they gave you pretty all-around good candidates, who you then selected for... social fit.
If I get asked these sort of insincere questions whose sole purpose are to judge, I'm just going to lie to you, to get this interview over with faster.
> Ask them hard questions, but don’t intimidate. Just go deep. The candidate cannot fake this. It’s not possible. People without the experience they claim are painfully obvious here.
It's possible. There are some very smooth talkers out there, and as much as we'd like to think we can spot bullshit: when the sums at stake are large, people will work very hard to do everything they can to get them. It's not that hard to bullshit a project you've never actually made before... you just take bits and pieces from other work and massage it until it all fits nicely (but not too nicely). With some skill, you can do this on the fly rather unconsciously, and just get in the zone.
I've done it before (for shits and giggles; never for employment opps I've ever accepted). It works best when you're talking about something the author clearly has no experience in (perhaps I could even be bullshitting this entire post?).
You really can't tell anything at all from a conversational interview besides: can this person hold a conversation? And minor inklings of whether or not the person is insane.
But otherwise, people lie, and misconstrue, and misrepresent, and plan beforehand. The only thing these conversations are going to do is confirm your own biases.
I'm more inclined to believe whoever set up your hiring pipeline did the majority of the work, and they gave you pretty all-around good candidates, who you then selected for... social fit.
If I get asked these sort of insincere questions whose sole purpose are to judge, I'm just going to lie to you, to get this interview over with faster.
> Ask them hard questions, but don’t intimidate. Just go deep. The candidate cannot fake this. It’s not possible. People without the experience they claim are painfully obvious here.
It's possible. There are some very smooth talkers out there, and as much as we'd like to think we can spot bullshit: when the sums at stake are large, people will work very hard to do everything they can to get them. It's not that hard to bullshit a project you've never actually made before... you just take bits and pieces from other work and massage it until it all fits nicely (but not too nicely). With some skill, you can do this on the fly rather unconsciously, and just get in the zone.
I've done it before (for shits and giggles; never for employment opps I've ever accepted). It works best when you're talking about something the author clearly has no experience in (perhaps I could even be bullshitting this entire post?).