Re:A modular system for isometric pixel blocks
by egypturnash on Friday January 13, 2023 @06:23PM
(#34375293)
This is from the studio "eboy", who's been doing professional isometric pixel work for a good while. When you're a multi-person studio who regularly does sprawling multi-artist projects (https://hello.eboy.com/pool/~Pixorama/1?q=project) then it's well worth documenting what you are choosing to standardize on.
I'm not a huge fan of their signature look either, but this is a nice little list of "what to expect if you're gonna work with us" IMHO. :)
Re:A modular system for isometric pixel blocks
by sublinear on Friday January 13, 2023 @07:25PM
(#34375855)
I think the asymmetry is a great rule that discourages the artist from just illogically and lazily flipping things.
Handedness in video game sprites is a great example of the weird dissonance created by mirroring.
Re:A modular system for isometric pixel blocks
by colejohnson66 on Friday January 13, 2023 @11:50PM
(#34377468)
RollerCoaster Tycoon isn't actually "pixel art", but, instead, renderings of 3D models. It just looks like pixel art because of the vibrant palette and small pixel-level art. Pixel art "techniques" do not apply because it wasn't drawn pixel-by-pixel.
Re:A modular system for isometric pixel blocks
by blueblimp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @03:11PM
(#34383706)
Interesting point. That's definitely visible in the overall art style.
But at least regarding the edges and corners of an isometric rectangular cuboid tile, I'm not convinced that there's a meaningful difference between pixel-by-pixel drawing vs non-anti-aliased rendering--the rendering turns out so precisely regular that it might as well have been drawn manually.
I checked two games: Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 and X-COM: UFO Defense. Interestingly, they solve the vertical line problem in the same way as each other, but it's in a different way from the link.
In those games, instead of having an explicit line border, the line is implied by a shading difference between the two faces, which eliminates the asymmetry. Additionally, the corners at top, middle, and bottom are 4 pixels wide instead of 2.
(This strengthens my conviction in the following rule of thumb: when it comes to art, it's better to study professional work I like than to trust a guide.)