News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by fullsend on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:16AM (#34351040)
In my opinion 90% of the reason we don’t have more accidents is because people are so predictable. Watch dangerous drivers weave through traffic - it’s only possible because everyone follows spoken and unspoken rules. Randomly stopping is not some “you need to be prepared, it’s your fault” moment.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by kosievdmerwe on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:39AM (#34351223)
A car switching into an empty lane and then stopping hard even more.

If a human driver did it deliberately as the Tesla did (since it was designed to pull over and stop) then I would consider it a criminal level traffic violation on the part of the stopping car.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by apigalore on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:45AM (#34351267)
I had an accident exactly like that. Car in front of me fully stopped all of a sudden as I was accelerating. This was right passed the lights. No traffic or anything in front him. I don't know why he stopped. My insurance told me he was 100% at fault.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by ArteEtMarte on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:03AM (#34351430)
Here in the UK, that happened to me on a roundabout. Elderly driver in front pulled out and then, for no visible reason, slammed on the brakes. I ran into the back of her.

It was deemed to be be 100% my fault. Here, if you run into the back of the car in front, it is always your fault. No exceptions.

It makes sense: you should always leave enough room to stop, so I couldn't really complain. But, if everybody did that on that particular busy roundabout, it would result in gridlock.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by Dzugaru on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:39AM (#34351667)
I've heard a story from a friend that was in an accident like that. A police officer who did the paperwork smiled and said "It's the most common type of accident - people just stop paying attention to the car in front that started moving, and develop sort of a blind spot to that".

I drive for several years, and can say my brain relies heavily on this sort of predictable stuff like "that car has free intersection in front of it, it will move forward".

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by qikInNdOutReply on Thursday January 12, 2023 @06:02AM (#34351844)
Crashed at a intersection into the driver in front of me. Started driving, and i looked wethere there was traffic coming from the left, the other driver in front of me stopped for no reason. Still my fault, but in some situations, with multiple dangers, you rely heavily on the people behaving predictable.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by sniglom on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:44AM (#34351692)
>It makes sense

If you think like a good citizen, yes.

In a country north of UK the law was once the same. People with worn down cars would find the perfect opportunity to slam their brakes, intentionally get hit from behind and claim insurance.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by rendall on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:39AM (#34351219)
> Randomly stopping is not some “you need to be prepared, it’s your fault” moment.

Drivers are indeed expected to always be prepared for sudden stops even at the highest speeds.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by samwillis on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:05AM (#34351440)
The other day I was driving behind a car on a country road, he did an emergency stop to avoid a rabbit in the road. I avoided hitting him, I stopped about 2m from him because I was careful to leave enough space. If I had hit him I'm sure the insurance companies would have placed blame on me and it would have been my insurance that paid out. But ultimately it would have been his "fault" for doing something utterly unpredictable and dangerously stupid.

If it had been a large deer, of course he should have stopped, at that point it's the safety of the people inside the car.

In law for insurance purposes it needs to be clear cut, person behind is almost always at fault. But that doesn't mean they are the cause of the accident in all cases. There is nuance to these things, and part of that is that braking for a rabbit, or using Level 2 automation, is increasing the chance of an accident happing on the road.

If the way you drive increases the risk of someone driving into the back of you, even if they haven't left enough space, you are at fault in my mind.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by dkrich on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:18AM (#34351528)
This reasoning makes very little sense to me. Why drive assuming that it will be a rabbit most of the time and not a child or a deer or whatever you deem worthy of stopping for?

If the possibility exists that a driver in front of you may stop suddenly why not always leave a minimum amount of space for a safe stop considering there is virtually no downside to doing so?

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by tpxl on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:38AM (#34351663)
> This reasoning makes very little sense to me.

The reasoning doesn't make sense because it is applied retroactively. The parent poster doesn't want to take responsibility for their unsafe driving practice and tries to place the blame on the other driver.

Cars suddenly stopping in front of you isn't some unpredictable rare event. You are told this as part of the licensing procedure, and this is the reason minimum safety distance exists. The solution is obvious and known to any licensed driver. As such, it is unreasonable and unacceptable, to not follow the minimum safety distance.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by samwillis on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:30AM (#34351603)
Thats not my point. You should, and I do, always leave enough space to stop, but not everyone does.

Being a safe driver is being aware that other people, including the people behind you, may not be leaving enough space. Suddenly stopping for a rabbit, from a speed of 50mph, is f-ing stupid and massively increasing the risk of a serious accident on the road.

Using a Level 2 automation that can randomly stop for no reason is not safe driving, you are increasing the chances that someone who is too close drives into the back of you.

Just because someone else is driving unsafely doesn't absolve you of the responsibility of being aware of that and not driving safely yourself.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by rjmunro on Thursday January 12, 2023 @09:37AM (#34354083)
You should be able to stop at any time for any reason and not worry about the car behind crashing in to you. They should leave enough space. A rabbit is a very good reason. Maybe it's not a rabbit, maybe it's a rabbit-shaped rock that would cause serious damage to your vehicle, causing you to leave the road and die.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by somethingreen on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:45AM (#34351705)
As long as there are valid reasons to do an emergency stop, the actual reason should be irrelevant for the person driving behind. You should always assume it is a child chasing their ball or something and it will be your car pushing the car that managed to properly stop into that child if you rear-end it. There just isn't a good reason to put yourself in a situation like that and it is perfectly in your power to avoid it.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by jmyeet on Thursday January 12, 2023 @06:07AM (#34351876)
I cycle a lot in an area that is quite touristy. There is a lot of shared infrastructure with pedestrians, rollerbladers, scooters and skateboarders. You get very good at spotting people who don’t know what they’re doing that are potentially dangerous usually because they’re oblivious to their surroundings.

For example, pedestrians crossing a bike path. Because a lot of people clearly don’t walk often they will just walk out without looking. People aware of their surroundings will look both ways. As soon as you see someone do that you can pass close to them without spooking them because you know they’re aware.

My point here is a ton of this comes down to acting predictably. Even a simple act like looking at someone will alleviate a ton of uncertainty.

The barriers to fully autonomous self-driving are huge and not necessarily technical. Acting predictably, being able to explain actions, drivers driving differently because another vehicle is automated and cultural differences.