News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by karlkloss on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:10AM (#34350579)
What happened to respecting the will of the voters?

Why do we take it for granted that we live in a democracy, but tolerate that businesses are directed like dictatorships?

That's insane.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by WalterBright on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:18AM (#34350628)
Democracy and freedom are not the same thing.

Don't I, as a free man, have the right to negotiate as I see fit with my employer? Why should that right be taken away by a vote of others?

Or let's put it another way. The Dems are for purple cars, the Reps are for yellow cars. We all get to vote on what we get! Is that freedom? What if I want a purple car, and the vote went yellow? What if I want a red car?

That isn't freedom.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by lopis on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:45AM (#34350793)
Aren't unions opt-in?
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by Dma54rhs on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:52AM (#34350839)
Unions in America are way different compared to Europe. It's worth reading about it.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by hughjd on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:38AM (#34351214)
Do you have a link or something to google at all? I tried variations of 'us vs europe union differences' but not getting anything relevant.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by Jensson on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:51AM (#34351323)
EU has right to work, that is a major one. I think the reason you don't see people talk about that online is that the left don't want to admit that right to work is pro workers, and the right don't want to use EU as a positive example.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by tchaffee on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:02AM (#34351420)
There's a lot more to it than that.

EU legislation establishes individual rights for all workers, with a maximum working week of 48 hours, paid annual leave of at least four weeks per year, rest periods and rules on night work, shift work and patterns of work.

Who needs unions with great labor laws already in place? Of course the right in the US want none of that.

A lot of EU law already in place is a wish list for US employees who join a union.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by kace91 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:31AM (#34351606)
> Who needs unions with great labor laws already in place?

That's kinda like asking 'who wants vaccines when we have this wonderful herd immunity?'

Unions are the reason those labor laws are there in the first place.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by tialaramex on Thursday January 12, 2023 @07:22AM (#34352457)
It's complicated. Unions do what their members want. But "what the members want" can be pretty different from what turns out to be a good idea in hindsight. Should children work down the coal mine? The view of somebody who wants that extra income from their 12 year old working in the mine may be quite different...

I support many union actions at my employer, for example I joined their recent strike, withholding my labour (and consequently getting paid less) because the employer and indeed their entire sector, refuses to make sensible pension and pay provisions - but I won't join the union itself because I don't agree with all their positions and I'm content with the trade off that results.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by tchaffee on Thursday January 12, 2023 @09:28AM (#34353939)
Are you sure that unions are responsible for the EU laws? Can you give any sources for that? I'm truly curious about it because the EU comes up with a lot of good consumer protection and worker laws and it's not obvious what motivates them to do so. Just as example, the law about universal phone chargers. Industry certainly didn't push them for that. Quite the opposite. So where did it come from other than it being a big plus for consumers and in reducing waste?
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by orwin on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:05PM (#34358743)
15 day PTO and the 40h week was brought by a conjunction of union work, general striking, and the first elected socialist government in France.

I dunno when the EU laws were created, but the 4th and the 5th week of PTO were also brought by unions (one with the help of q socialist government). The other 14 days (we have 39 total PTO in France, 14 of those can be redeemed as money basically) i don't know where they came from.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by tchaffee on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:56PM (#34361445)
> and the first elected socialist government in France.

So that's the missing piece I was looking for. I think you'll find something similar in Italy.

The big difference in the US is that Americans have never elected a truly labor friendly government. These laws in the EU are not just the result of strong unions. You need government to be on board too and that requires the voters.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by kace91 on Friday January 13, 2023 @09:10PM (#34376655)
> I'm truly curious about it because the EU comes up with a lot of good consumer protection and worker laws and it's not obvious what motivates them to do so.

This is less directly related to unions.

The EU was founded as two basic principles - free movement of goods, free movement of workers. The idea was to achieve a common comercial block that could compete in the era of superpowers.

What we’ve come to realize is that those basic principles end up almost building a country from the ground up:

You can’t have workers from france outcompeting germans by selling lower quality meat because the French don’t have to follow German animal health standards. So, common health standards for everyone.

You can’t have an Italian company outselling Spanish companies because the Spanish lose money repairing defective products and the Italians don’t have to. So common consumer laws.

keep going and we’ll eventually have an army to protect our interests, etc. and we’ll become a federal country of sorts.

That explains why the EU creates standards. We all have to compete under the same rules.

As for why set the standard as “improving rights for everyone” rather than “lowering rights to the minimum for everyone”, it is always going to be more popular to raise the standards, rather than be an institution that takes rights away from citizens of the member nations. If the EU was seen as the big guys that force you to work and live in worse conditions it would not last long.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by Jensson on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:14AM (#34351490)
But that just makes right to work seem even better, EU where workers don't need to pay unions to get rights still pay their unions and are way more willing to join unions. So to me demonising right to work doesn't make sense, California could add those worker protections if they wanted, I see no reason at all why they need workers to give up their rights so that unions can take their money.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by tchaffee on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:20AM (#34351545)
You need the strong labor laws first which the US does not have. Right to work in the US is popular in states with the worst labor laws and mostly the poor states.

Right to work could be good under the right conditions. Which the EU already largely has. In fact many EU countries have far stronger labor laws than the EU laws themselves. That's the context within which right to work starts to make sense.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by Jensson on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:32AM (#34351621)
If you have the power to take away right to work from your workers then you also have the power to give them good conditions like paid vacation instead. I see no reason ever why you would remove right to work in that situation instead of just legislating proper worker rights, except to feed unions.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by tchaffee on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:44AM (#34351691)
> I see no reason ever why you would remove right to work in that situation instead of just legislating proper worker rights, except to feed unions.

The massive wealth gaps in the US tell the actual story. Corporations have a huge influence over US law and the laws mostly benefit the corporations over individuals or unions. That's one of the dangers of massive wealth. You can just buy the government. Which has already happened in the US.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by WalterBright on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:46AM (#34350800)
What's the point of the vote, then?
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by mdpye on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:00AM (#34350904)
Those who have opted in choose to be bound by the vote in exchange for the increased bargaining power that a consistent position affords, right?

In the car analogy, you're missing the "free to not have any car at all even though you would like one" option.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by WalterBright on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:19AM (#34351063)
Again, what's the point of a vote to form a union, if you can be in a union or not as you choose? The ones who want a union can just make one.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by Jensson on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:30AM (#34351147)
Yeah, that is how it works in Europe. In Europe we protected workers against unions, so workers don't have to be as afraid of unions. In USA they protected unions against workers, so that unions don't have to be afraid of workers, no wonder unions aren't popular then...
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by mdpye on Friday January 13, 2023 @10:37AM (#34369207)
Right, I misunderstood which vote were were talking about, sorry. I thought we were talking about voting on union action (e.g. to strike, or to accept a specific deal in a negotiation)
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by caskstrength on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:47AM (#34351275)
I'm not from US, but I would assume unions are only opt-in in right-to-work states. NYC is not one of them.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by cool_dude85 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @07:10AM (#34352342)
Common misconception, also seen among many of the replies. Unions are not opt-in, unless you consider "taking a union job" opt-in.

If this vote goes through (and a contract agreed), and you take a unionized job in the unionized warehouse, you will be covered by the union contract. If management violates the contract in a way that harms you, the union will be filing a grievance on your behalf. If you ask for a union rep to be in the room when discipline is discussed, they must send a rep. You will vote on a proposed contract. In short, the union has the responsibility to represent you, based on your being in a union job.

A "right to work" state is one where the union cannot sign a contract with the employer forcing you to pay union dues in order to get the representation you are entitled to. So, you have the right, in a "right to work" state, to avail yourself of the union representation without paying dues. That's exactly what "right to work" means, and no more.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by namdnay on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:36AM (#34351191)
So what’s your alternative? At the end of the day, certain things can only work if we align everyone. You can’t have half the electorate paying 10% tax but no police service and half the country paying 15% tax but getting police
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by WalterBright on Thursday January 12, 2023 @04:40AM (#34351228)
That's under the government's purview. It has nothing to do with employees vs business. Unless you're arguing that businesses should be operated by the government.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by namdnay on Thursday January 12, 2023 @06:01AM (#34351833)
you just said

> Or let's put it another way. The Dems are for purple cars, the Reps are for yellow cars. We all get to vote on what we get! Is that freedom? What if I want a purple car, and the vote went yellow? What if I want a red car?

you weren't talking about government here?

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by CPLX on Thursday January 12, 2023 @06:15AM (#34351935)
The reasons for people to band together in the form of government to collectively hire police and to band together as a union to collectively bargain with employers are the same, namely to protect members of society from those who would cause them harm.

The idea of “freedom” from government as a frame of reference here is bullshit. The entire concept of a corporation is a government created legal fiction, and an arbitrary one. Corporations are required to do hundreds of thousands of things.

Jeff Bezos can rent a warehouse and talk people into going there and do whatever the fuck he wants. But if he wants limited liability, access to the roads and waterways the society creates and manages, enforcement of property rights, and the permission to enter a joint stock partnership to fund it he needs government permission, also known as the permission of society.

The fact of Amazon even existing at all is a privilege granted by the state that can be revoked at any time.

I don’t have the freedom to negotiate as I see fit with my employer. I also don’t have the freedom to punch Jeff Bezos in the nuts for not paying fair wages and I am not allowed to be a hairdresser if I don’t pass an exam or sell securities without registering them or pork that I’ve been storing in my attic all week.

We regulate every single aspect of commerce, it’s a choice we’ve made as a society.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by simple-thoughts on Thursday January 12, 2023 @07:11AM (#34352358)
This is correct. All modern corporations are extensions of the state and should be viewed no differently than government agencies. Privately owned and operated entities are a different matter, as these have existed long before the state and continue to exist today in stateless zones.
Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by nickpp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @05:32AM (#34379107)
> The reasons for people to band together in the form of government [...] to protect members of society from those who would cause them harm.

Or to exploit and rob minority members of said society. The "good willed" government does not exist and has no reason to: it owns the ultimate monopoly, on violence. Most governments today on the planet are evil. The list of atrocities perpetrated by governments is as long as civilization's history and completely dwarfs the list of bad things done by corporations.

> The fact of Amazon even existing at all is a privilege granted by the state that can be revoked at any time.

States tried getting rid of corporations. Their citizens starved. The truth is, most value created by companies is captured by the society at large (the value we get from the stuff we buy is much larger than the cost we pay), not the company owners or employees.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by jfengel on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:38PM (#34358344)
Businesses have always been dictatorships. It's only governments that are democracies.

The will of the voters that matters in this case is the voters who voted for labor laws. (Or rather, voters who voted for politicians, who voted for labor laws.) And, of course, the voters who voted for the Supreme Court, who gets to singlehandedly say what those laws actually mean. (Again, they don't vote directly; they vote for a President who nominates and a Senate who approves.)

The vote of a union only matters in light of those labor laws. And the company has the right to appeal those, under those same laws.

It would be nice for the company to also take the responsibility to respect the intention of the law, rather than hoping they'll get some body (elected or otherwise) to give them the answer they wanted. But our whole system is deliberately adversarial: everybody fights as hard as they can for what they want, regardless of what would actually be right. That's a big chunk of the reason we have unions in the first place.

It's a terrible system, the worst one, except for all of the others. Me, I'm voting with my feet: I'm using Amazon as little as I can get away with, even when it costs more to use an alternative. They can fix that by ceasing to be douchebags... but that seems pretty unlikely.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by kelseyfrog on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:42PM (#34359239)
I'm not buying it. Monarchy was the best system ever tried until democracy gained prominence.

Voting with feet and voting with dollars has always been a way to make workers and consumers(often the same) feel like they've got a say without actually giving them one.

The problem is that the territory of the conflict is attempting to be constrained ie: within the current legal structure. What isn't allowed here is the conflict to spill into the province of arguing about the rules of the game itself. We've never had a static legal landscape and never will, and yet arguments like these assume it.

Workers should have a shot at workplace democracy because it's a fundamental right of self-determination. Carve-outs of that right like in workplaces are only as natural as we make them.

Re:Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten... by jfengel on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:49PM (#34361371)
Hey, I don't disagree. I'm just explaining how it works: just because a bunch of people get together to vote on something doesn't make it binding. Maybe it should, but it doesn't.

There's a million things I'd do differently if I were in charge. But not only am I not in charge, what little power I do possess has been systematically diluted to the point of effective nonexistence.