News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by Eisenstein on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:39PM (#34349285)
Do you understand the point the parent was making? The children's market is not what VR developers are going for. For one: COPPA kinda makes monetizing VR spaces not possible; two: some parents might let their kids have one, but right on the device it says not to let kids under 12 use it, so I doubt most will. Mainstream consumer adoption is not squeaky voiced pre-teens.
Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by dmix on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:41PM (#34349298)
Right, so you are saying you've never actually used VR for an extended period of time.

Spend 15min on any popular VR multiplayer game and tell me kids under 12 aren't using it en-masse.

Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by Eisenstein on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:43PM (#34349313)
Do you not understand arguments or do you just ignore points you don't like? I am not contending that children don't use it. I am contending that children using it to any extent is not desired by the manufacturers nor does it count as mainstream consumer adoption. Please don't respond again about how kids use it.
Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by dmix on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:45PM (#34349328)
So your argument is parental pearl-clutching will kill it? Despite the widespread adoption among young early-adopters and price ranges showing it will eventually allow it to penetrate beyond niche casual gaming to higher ends of the market.

I recommend you read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossing_the_Chasm

Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by Eisenstein on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:57PM (#34349397)
No, I told you exactly what my argument was and you refuse to acknowledge it and make up your own instead. I find you frustrating to converse with so I shall exit this conversation.

Also, your 5 minute later post-edits are ridiculous. You add completely new sentences.

Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by dmix on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:02AM (#34349427)
Since I doubt you've read the book then I'll explain it to you.

You don't mainstream technology via your early adopter market. To succeed you need to mature tech and adapt it to a general market.

So the fact some rarely-enforced children protection laws or hypothetical cultural parenting rules might hurt VR IF the only market was merely kids in the long run. But that's not what I'm saying.

VR's market in the future isn't casual gaming for kids. My point is that's all it is now. And for that it's doing a great job and has a real lively market to fund the tech. Your fears haven't born true for early adopters (because it's fundamentally a mainstream critique), so it doesn't really matter, as long as it's sufficient fuel the tech til it bridges the gap and the tech matures.

(btw edit sniping is your problem, not mine)

Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by mastazi on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:45AM (#34350032)
FWIW where the original comment said

> It's not something you can do with kids around

I think the author of that comment meant that if you have little kids, you need to keep an eye on them, and playing with a headset that blocks your peripheral vision is not going to be something a parent can do in that situation.

That comment didn't mean to say that kids would not play VR. It was suggesting that parents wouldn't.

Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by dmix on Thursday January 12, 2023 @10:00PM (#34363470)
Again all I'm saying is what matters is that enough kids do in fact play VR, today, to fuel the tech so it can mature into a mainstream technology. The only way this hypothetical (future) parent issue would discredit VR as a mainstream technical innovation is for VR companies to have bet solely on causal/kid gaming for their long term success.

This is why OP missed the point. Because I didn't agree that that was an important point he a) got emotional for being disagreed with b) assumed that I thought it wasn't true. But I only ever said it didn't matter, not that parents or regulations dont have power in this dynamic.

Evidence points to Quest 2 being very popular among kids and their casual gaming platform via Android-esque VR games has provided a strong and sufficient market from which multiple companies can mature the technology to a wider market.

It was a faulty premise to dismiss the technology, because it fundamentally mischaracterizes how technology normally mainstreams (by first having a real and successful initial early adopter market from which you adapt and mature to mainstream markets - not betting on early adopters to BE the mainstream).

Although I will agree I probably should have said "yes you're right" so OP didn't feel I misunderstood. Altough if he wasn't so quick to win an internet "fight" he might have let me explain.

Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by jsjohnst on Thursday January 12, 2023 @08:15AM (#34352995)
> (Edit sniping is your problem, my goal isn't to win fast-paced internet arguments but to communicate my points as well as I can)

Then slow down and take a breath before hitting the reply button the first time. Pausing and then rereading and proofing as needed rather than fast-paced posting with fast-paced follow up edits is the way to go. This is coming from someone who also used to very often tweak my posts after initial posting.

Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by dmix on Thursday January 12, 2023 @09:46PM (#34363369)
Fair enough, I tend to over use edit on HN more than other sites because I never cared to win flame wars, but it does help improve the quality of the replies you get from people, as seen here. So noted.
Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by shkkmo on Thursday January 12, 2023 @09:45AM (#34354194)
> (Edit sniping is your problem, my goal isn't to win fast-paced internet arguments but to communicate my points as well as I can)

It is a problem for everyone who reads the comment thread. Please either wait to post long enough re-read and edit, or indicate which sentences have been added later. (Edit: the latter is commonly done like this.)

Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by dmix on Thursday January 12, 2023 @10:07PM (#34363509)
He replied to 2 of my comments <1 min when I made some additions 2-3min after (and I didnt change my arguments just expanded). I'm not on HN to win fast paced arguments. But I do understand that some people are.

In the future I will take this into consideration re: using "Edit:" for people who reply before you even notice.

Re:HoloKit relaunched, $129 AR Headset accessory for iPhone by gernb on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:30AM (#34349584)
> The children's market is not what VR developers are going for.

I think VR developers would be happy to have children's market as big as Nintendo's