Yes it is a balance between barrier to entry and public content, but I think the default should be the common case that benefits everyone - the public domain. I wouldn't want the registration process to be arduous or expensive though.
2. I agree (and this would solve the biggest problem with implied copyright, it's length).
3. You could claim non-commercial, profitless use of an album and share it freely - albums are a poor way to make money in the internet connected world. In my system they'd be thought of more as promotion for merchandise and tours. The fact that distribution is cheap and sharing is essentially free can be used as advantages. This would be a big difference, but I think the efforts would be better served in working with technology then artificially trying to prevent it from what it does well. I think the old way of doing things is only viable with draconian measures that don't benefit the public.
There's a lot of waste in the current system that doesn't need to be there, but the old distribution channels seem to want to create legislation to necessitate their existence rather than adapt.
2. 14 years is more than reasonable for a first pass before it enters the public domain. The reason it got up to 70 was because Disney didn't want Mickey Mouse to enter the public domain. The chief proponents of this are corporations, since they have lifespans much longer than you or I. They were retroactive because of Disney wanting to create new properties with the Mickey Mouse likeness.
3. That's high and mighty of you, but what determines "non-profit"? Surely you mean non-commercial? At any rate, then you or I could claim a profitless, personal use of an album that gets released, and share it freely. I'm very much a proponent of the idea of "fair use," but to say that "non-profit sharing is not illegal" is a little naive, methinks.