edit: no, you can't... post hoc correlation analysis is an exercise in obscurity. If there was internal logic to the movements looking back, there would be a possibility of forecasting them.
Interest rates play a role, but it's not the direct cause you're thinking of. The value of a company is related to the risk-free rate of return, i.e. interest rate set by the government. Lower interest rates produce higher valuations, and higher rates produce lower valuations. But just because a company's market value goes down as the interest rises doesn't mean the company was inherently overvalued at the lower interest rate.
What we saw in the tech market was that companies were overvalued. The change in interest rate was the catalyst for tech's value adjustment, but the companies were overvalued at the old interest rate, too, because their value was based in-part on unrealistic growth expectation. Also, ZIRP really messed with market dynamics. Look at crypto, which is something that has near-zero utility and thus should have near-zero value, especially all the random shitcoins. Many such shitcoins were worth many millions / billions of dollars. The market was clearly irrationally valuing many different types of assets.
It seems pretty obvious if interest rates are high, tech companies which make most of their profits far in the future were going to be worth less than value companies where most of their profits are in the short term.
Nobody can predict the future, not even you.
Obviously I can't know one way or the other, but I laid out my personal belief in the original post. Essentially, many "tech" companies are just digital versions or existing business and products. In such cases, there isn't as much value to capture compared to unlocking massive amounts of human potential like a company like Google. The market, however, was valuing these two types of tech companies the same. Peloton is a good example. Peloton is a great product and can really make a dent in the home-gym market. But the home-gym market is already relatively mature, so Peloton really shouldn't have been commanding such insane multiples on any metric (sales, revenue, cash flow, etc.)
It makes much more sense they just plugged in a higher discount rate to their models.
Peloton has fallen because they went from a company with rapidly growing revenue to one falling revenue.
Exactly. Their growth expectations were unrealistic. They were bringing a marginally better product to a saturated market under the guise of being a tech company. They could be a good business if run lean, but they’ll never realistically command insane multiples on revenue.
The idea that Apple is "taking on debt to buy back stock" is pretty misleading. Sure, Apple has some debt - but it has net cash. Ditto for the rest of the megacap tech stocks.
When risk-free rates of return increase, that harms the value of all growth companies by increasing the discount rate applied to future cash flows (while not giving a corresponding "credit" for near-term losses of cash)
Many of these companies were losing money and their future imaginary positive cash flows were wishful thinking given their business models. Higher interest rates accelerated loss in value as the speculative sentiment shifted to a more risk-averse posture once the market accepted the reality that was always there: these companies never exhibited the ability to make any money, plus they were cannibalizing themselves due to the extreme competition from other startups fueled by the huge amounts of money vc’s were able to gather during the zero interest rate mania.
Discounting future negative cashflows was always a foolish game.
If I have a company that will lose 100 units of currency this year and next year, break even the year after that, and then return 20 units of currency for each of the next 17 years, then vanish without a trace, that's worth positive 46 units of currency at a 3% discount, nothing at a 5% discount, and negative 37 units of currency at a 7% discount rate. (Whether you discount the initial losses changes the analysis by only a small amount.)
Initial cash flows weigh much more heavily than later cash flows, so initial losses in a cash flow series have a much larger impact on npv. Therefore, I disagree with the conclusion of your hypothetical.
the most talked-about layoffs right now are happening at salesforce, facebook, amazon, etc. I'm not sure what you are trying to convey or which hypothetical companies you are talking about, but they are printing money.
Why can't Apple buy its stock from Ireland without paying more taxes?
and it’s not misleading at all. Apple and Meta are both known to sell bonds aka taking on debt for the primary purpose of buying back their own stock. that doesn’t have anything to do with their multibillion pile of cash.
Apple has many times. I don’t know why this is suddenly a conspiracy that some mega cap tech firms used cheap debt to buy back their stock. It’s not. It’s actually the primary way that these companies hid dilution from investors due to employee stock comp.
That's actually not accurate. NTM revenue multiples for software companies peaked at ~12.0x on average in October 2021. The first rate hike in this cycle happened in March 2022.
Big companies like Facebook aren't funding their operations with debt. They're absolutely flush with cash. Your claim that the fed raising rates is causing layoffs in these large, profitable companies does not hold water.
Does that help to explain a retreat in VC- and other debt-funded entities? Sure. But the headline layoffs we've seen are not in those types of companies.
Now, I do agree that growth projections were revised down, but the explanation for that is much simpler: A lot of companies assumed COVID was going to create a lasting impact on the world that would result in endless growth and revenues for companies like Peloton, Zoom, etc.
Well, that didn't happen, and they are now forced to cut back on staff after over-hiring due to those bad projections.
This pattern is visible across the industry. It's not in the least bit mysterious.
Discounting NPV of future cashflows affects stock price. No argument there.
Okay.
So what?
Why would a dropping stock price motivate layoffs?
The GP's claim is that it's because it makes debt more expensive (which it does!)
> when borrowing money becomes more expensive, these companies can no longer fuel business expansion or stock buybacks with cheap debt
But unless you're funding you're operations with debt, that just doesn't matter that much, and in fact it can have a positive effect because it makes stock buybacks cheaper (looking at you, Apple).
That means businesses planning to, say, open a new factory or expand into a new market, might choose to delay or cancel those plans, and that can certainly impact growth projections.
But the tech megacorps aren't typically growing that way anymore. And even in the case of a company like Meta, which is investing heavily in their "metaverse" vision, they're funding that with cash because they're money printing machines.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/137623-how-interest-rates-i...
> First, assume that our opinion of future free cash flow doesn’t change so as to isolate the effect that the discount rate will have on value. You can think of the discount rate as the opportunity cost of investing in Stock A over Stock B or Investment C. If interest rates rise, so too should our discount rate since we would have more opportunities to do more with our money elsewhere. And since discount rates and present values are inversely related, value will decline, all else equal, as the result of a rise in interest rates.
https://www.graduatetutor.com/corporate-finance-tutoring/cas...
> The first way in which interest rates factor into a DCF model is through the discount rate. The discount rate captures the rate at which the value of money declines. Prevailing interest rates are a big factor in opportunity cost. And opportunity cost is an ingredient of the discount rate.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/dcf.asp
> Calculating the DCF involves three basic steps. One, forecast the expected cash flows from the investment. Two, select a discount rate, typically based on the cost of financing the investment or the opportunity cost presented by alternative investments. Three, discount the forecasted cash flows back to the present day, using a financial calculator, a spreadsheet, or a manual calculation.
So DCF analysis doesn't actually say anything about company's actual future cashflows. It's about the value of those cashflows to the investor when weighing the value of that stock versus other types of investments.
Bringing us back to the topic at hand, that means higher interest rates should depress stock prices because of the increased opportunity cost versus investing in other assets.
what's weird to me is that this is happening at all kinds of companies, including ones with what I thought was pretty level-headed management. It's not just one company oops screwed up and over-hired, and "tech" is not really a monolith. Yet, they somehow all simultaneously screwed up and over-hired?
The idea is that many--especially very high profile companies--overhired, and the rest are following the leader.
Stir in media hysteria around purported recessions and you can understand why leadership might start to pull the reins.
tech valuations have come down because the Fed has raised rates which long duration stocks like growths tech cos are extremely sensitive to.
when borrowing money becomes more expensive, these companies can no longer fuel business expansion or stock buybacks with cheap debt, and at the same time facing a demand issue because consumers are facing the same phenomenon.
lower growth projections combined with expanding operating costs due to headcount are unsustainable for growthy tech firms that normally burn a lot of cash to fuel growth, so it becomes necessary for these firms to slow hiring and layoff workers to slow their burn and conserve cash.