News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Daily Habits of Happiness Experts by bryanlarsen on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:10AM (#34339246)
This is an example of where English falls down. Your definition of happiness appears to be almost the complete opposite of the definition used in the article.

This is also very well trod ground, Plato did a good job on it.

Plato would have called your definition of happiness hedonism.

He would have called the articles definition of happiness eudaimonism, and that lines up pretty good with what you said can make you miserable. Plato and happiness scientists generally agree that eudaimonism is the best route to long term happiness.

Perhaps we should just stop using the word happiness and use the words pleasure and satisfaction instead.

Re:The Daily Habits of Happiness Experts by kaon123 on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:05AM (#34339936)
Yes! Often satisfaction and pleasure are in a conflicting relationship.

When you ask a software developer that has worked for 3 years on a "successful" side project. He will probably tell you that it cost him lots of evenings he could have been seeing friends or sleeping. Yet that same person may feel very satisfied for having done so.

Still. It is difficult territory. Dissatisfaction is often leads to action that can then lead to "societal success". Should you be dissatisfied then? The Tony Robbinses of the world might say yes!

Re:The Daily Habits of Happiness Experts by circlefavshape on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:20AM (#34340153)
> Plato and happiness scientists generally agree that eudaimonism is the best route to long term happiness.

I think you're misconstruing this a bit. Plato and some happiness scientists see eudaimonia as superior to "affect" (the actual emotional state of "happy"). One is not a route to the other.

Daniel Kahneman is, as far as I can make out, a hedonist and so, fwiw, am I. To me eudaimonia is just smugness

Re:The Daily Habits of Happiness Experts by boh on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @12:09PM (#34340972)
Happiness is similar to the word "freedom" , in that it can mean anything to anyone (with freedom used in equal measure by rebels, despots and used car salesmen). Words like these are more used for emotional aesthetics rather than a descriptive expression. These words are so persistent in our culture because they essentially have no meaning. It doesn't matter how the article or "happiness experts" define happiness because their definitions are circumstantial and irrelevant. The meaningless of the word "happiness" remains intact. It's closer to a secular faith than an actual phenomenon. Yes you might've felt happy but a persistent state of "happiness" is more a sign of a manic episode than an actual reality you can buy for yourself or hire someone (like the ridiculous people in the article) to achieve.