News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:App Engine charges $6,500 to update a ListProperty on 14.... by acdha on Friday January 06, 2012 @10:34AM (#3433639)
You're leaving out several key parts:

* reddit on GAE would have no options if they ran into a feature which is too expensive on the GAE architecture. Reddit on EC2 has been able to change their backend architecture dramatically to deal with growth and new features — that's a really powerful thing to give up since it means you aren't limited to GAE's lowest-common-denominator functionality.

* Even assuming reddit could affort to spend kilobucks per day on GAE, how many good sysadmins and developers could they hire for that same amount of money? At their scale, the answer is a LOT of people - and that gives a lot more flexibility since money going to GAE is a sunk cost which scales linearly with traffic whereas people generally give better than linear returns.

Re:App Engine charges $6,500 to update a ListProperty on 14.... by stickfigure on Friday January 06, 2012 @03:15PM (#3434846)
reddit on GAE would have no options

This is not true at all. It's very easy to run a hybrid with parts of your application in other parts of the cloud. I do this. There's even a remote API stub so you have direct access to the full suite of GAE APIs from servers in EC2 or whatnot.

There are certainly limitations to what you can run inside of GAE, but there's almost always a good way to work around it while preserving the benefits of scalability, multi-datacenter reliability, etc. I'm not saying it's for everyone, but it's great for most common web applications.

Re:App Engine charges $6,500 to update a ListProperty on 14.... by marshallp on Friday January 06, 2012 @01:45PM (#3434470)
Costs between aws and gae are roughly the same, and architectures when you get above rdbms's are also the roughly the same.

The only real difference is that gae forces you to code for scalability while aws leaves with possibilities to shoot yourself in the foot, which reddit apparently does.