Re:Tell HN: We Need Robots.txt but for AI
by danShumway on Tuesday January 10, 2023 @05:59PM
(#34332721)
But unless you have a plan to convince the average person on the street, and the president, and a fillibuster-proof majority of Congress, and a number of international US allies that copyright was a mistake, comparing AI-training on copyrighted material to the printing press is an invitation to create regulation, not an argument against that regulation.
Re:Tell HN: We Need Robots.txt but for AI
by pwinnski on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @12:24PM
(#34341192)
I agree that copyright as it exists today is ridiculous, but a complete lack of copyright would destroy a large number of industries that currently exist, and for little benefit.
I'm all for pulling things back to the terms originally in place in the US, for example, despite the changes that would bring to society. But the answers to the questions asked still seemed pretty clear.
There's meaningful evidence that copyright slows knowledge sharing and evolution.
Profitable for a single creator, a problem for mankind.