Re:Alan Kay on “Should web browsers have stuck to being docu...
by TeMPOraL on Monday January 09, 2023 @08:20AM
(#34309985)
Unfortunately we know now it wouldn't have helped much in practice. Take your GPS example: you can spoof GPS on Android, globally or per-app. Of the apps that are actually useful, many (most?) of the ones that want/need location data will attempt to detect GPS spoofing and deny you service until you turn it off.
And lest you think you can work around this by rooting your phone, an increasing number of actually useful apps refuse to run on rooted devices, "because security", and Google is actively helping this by making available an API that streamlines those checks.
Capability-based security is a good idea, but like all security technology, it only helps the owner of a device, and who is the owner of a device in any given context is a contested topic, with platforms, vendors, manufacturers and users all having a different opinion about it.
And lest you think you can work around this by rooting your phone, an increasing number of actually useful apps refuse to run on rooted devices, "because security", and Google is actively helping this by making available an API that streamlines those checks.
Capability-based security is a good idea, but like all security technology, it only helps the owner of a device, and who is the owner of a device in any given context is a contested topic, with platforms, vendors, manufacturers and users all having a different opinion about it.