$6,750,000: money
Interest paid on the remaining $5MM: other money
I'm seeing two sums of money and two taxes, a 1:1 ratio. Where's the double taxation?
I have no qualms about paying captial gains tax. But the blogger's comparison of capital gains tax vs. income tax is incorrect.
If I earn $6.75mm, then pay tax on it, I have $5mm.
Then I have $5mm in the bank and go get a job and earn another $100k, I'm only taxed (via income tax) on that $100k.
Similarly, if I have $5mm in the bank and it earns me $100k, I'm only taxed (via capital gains) on that $100k.
They are parallel taxes... not taxing the same money. The $100k is either earned income or investment income, and the $6.75mm was only ever earned income.
With dividends, it's easy to see that they are double taxed, but is that wrong? Your regular paycheck is double taxed too... first with income tax and then (in most states) with sales tax. There is nothing inherently amoral about double taxation, although it is kind of annoying how it hides your total tax rate.
To me, the annoyance of capital gains taxes is that it creates an entirely parallel tax rate structure, adding complexity (like everything Congress does with the tax code). If capital gains were treated like normal income, and capital losses (up to a certain amount) were treated like normal deductions, then taxes would be a lot easier for most people to file.
Same goes with sales tax. The fact that the government has turned every retail business in the country into a tax collector was an enormous coup. The system is impractical and a pain for businesses, placing the burden on them to raise funds for the states. It's also a massively regressive tax. Due to the impractical implementation, you can't even try to fix the regressive nature. States really need to find a better way to fund themselves.
If I hire an employee, I have to pay payroll taxes on the salary I pay him or her, and then I also have to pay business taxes on the value that the employee gives to the company in the form of increased revenue. Is this "double taxation" also a cause for moral outrage?
All I can think of is defense (not offense), intelligence, (poorly executed) safety nets, (some) education and (some) infrastructure.
Lot of qualifiers, which exemplifies the problem.
Tax rates are determined (well, should be) by what works. If some double taxation is good for the nation, more power to it.
A statement like the one you made really needs further reasoning to back it up. You might even be correct - but just claiming something to be true doesn't make it so.
Our tax system has to try and fix one of the fundamental flaws of capitalism -- the tendency for the rich to get richer and the poor to get poorer. Without a capital gains tax, this very worst aspect of capitalism becomes even more emphasized, as capital will last forever.
Certainly, the rich may get rich faster than the poor, but that's far from the same thing.
BS. Riches to shirtsleeves abound. Wealth rarely lasts three generations. Now, there are certain subgroups that seem mired in poverty, but that's another matter. The extent to which the rich have been getting richer and the poor getting poorer for the last 30 years in America has everything to do with the explosive growth of government and regulation, NOT capitalism.
Capital gains should be zero. All wealth creation is driven by savings and capital. Maximized capital investment and the incentives to save, maximize growth.
Income taxes should also be zero, by the way. It is entirely feasible to fund a properly scoped government with excise, duties, and user fees.
Entrepreneurs "have business to do" as Mark puts it because they stand to make some money from their efforts. The less money they stand to make, the less incentive. period.
Also, you state the following as if its fact:
"what capital gains taxes really do is favor the ultra-wealthy who live off of their investments, rather than those generating wealth directly"
No. In order for the ultra-rich person in your example to have accumulated $5M, he EARNED $6,750,000 and paid the government $1,750,000. So, by paying tax on his investment income, he's paying tax twice on the same money. That simple error aside, you're also missing the point that capital gains tax discourages investing in companies! Which has an impact on a company's cost of capital which has an impact on the price of goods and services which has an impact on you.