Re:Amen Brother Cuban
by Prrometheus on Friday October 24, 2008 @08:11PM
(#343158)
If, by some miracle, you managed to simplify the tax code, then lobbyists would be there the next day trying to add loopholes to it for their clients. Without constraints on government (and ours has none de facto) there is plunder to be had in Washington, and people respond to incentives.
You'd penalize the investment gains with double taxation. The person already paid income taxes on the money that was used to generate the $25K. Why should government policy penalize savings and investment?
Because it's not necessarily in our interest to favor capital over labor.
So if I buy a lottery ticket for $1 and then use it to win $50 million I shouldn't be paying taxes on the $50 million because I already paid income taxes on the $1?
Re:Amen Brother Cuban
by timcederman on Friday October 24, 2008 @06:56PM
(#343075)
The knock-on effects are why tax law is as (necessarily) convoluted as it is.
Also, just simplify the entire thing and have a simpler tax rate. It may also be interesting to see what happens if the party responsible for what tax dollars are spent on is not the same party that decides the allocation of the money. Group 1 creates a list of priorities A, B, C but voters then get to choose the tax dollar allocation.