News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by mannykannot on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:38AM (#34299000)
The authors concede that what they call algorithmic AI could, in principle, mimic organic intelligence arbitrarily closely. To maintain that this is not intelligence without begging the question, they need to have some relevant difference between the two which is not simply saying that Turing machines and living organisms are different categories. From the discussion (and especially section 7) it is clear that all their attempts to defend their position will fall back on one thing: Turing machines are deterministic.

The simplest response to that is that as soon as a machine (including a digital computer) is interacting with the real world, it is tapping into a source of entropy and its behavior is no longer determined fully by its programming. Alternatively, if one holds that the universe is deterministic, then living organisms are, which also defeats the author's last stand.

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by joshspankit on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:45AM (#34299046)
It’s funny to me to see this juxtaposed with the arguments from the other side:

Society had long argued that animals were not intelligent, and that instincts were deterministic.

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by pnf on Sunday January 08, 2023 @11:06AM (#34300212)
Instincts in animals (including humans) are deterministic insofar as they determine the behavior of the animal. A bird may choose one stick or another but it can't choose not to build a nest. A human can. This may be unique to humans. Heidegger refers to this as world-openness, meaning our world is not closed by our instincts. Unlike most animals, humans don't possess enough instincts to survive in nature. We are "insufficiently-determined". Hence, to survive, we augment our nature with our culture, which acts as a second nature within which we can act unthinkingly (as animals do). Without this second nature we shall surely die (hence the furious culture wars). Not incidentally, this is one of the anthropological arguments against state of nature political theories: there's no such thing and never has been in the history of the species.

Animals may be more or less undetermined but a bee will make honey and an ant will gather food regardless of any individual instance of bee or ant intelligence.

The problem with the above objection is that there is no account of "meaning" in what an AGI does. In other words, it's still a computer. To say that the entropy of the system will determine the entity's indeterminism is akin to arguments saying Schrodinger's cat is evidence for the possibility of human free will. It's a category error. Unless you want to argue that humans are also computers (which is the position of many strict materialists) then there is still a huge gap to account for in terms of meaning that can't be defined away satisfyingly. We all know what it's like to be an intelligence. At best, people say we can't know if an AGI also knows that because we can't inspect their "minds". This argument is justified by recourse to the principle of the multiple instantiability of intelligence. If we admit that non-carbon-based life forms could be intelligent (e.g., extraterrestrials) then we may admit that intelligence could be in silica as well. Without the ability to introspect other minds, we assume they are like ours and not simply "zombies". The above arguments (reducible to "Well, how do you KNOW anyone else has a mind?") are based in a kind of skeptical solipsism. The part about intelligence being demarcated by non-determinism and the way that argument fails is a side-step of the hard problem of consciousness.

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by nb3423 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:28PM (#34304547)
Humans actually take very little to non relevant decisions. The "free will" is mostly an illusion, you "choose" between equivalent options, not between actually different "life paths".

You can "decide" you won't "build a nest", but you'll certainly look for refuge if it is raining, or it's very cold. In the end, the human behavior is actually fully deterministic.

I'm sure FAANG already know this because they have the datapoints from billions of humans beings doing exactly the same stuff everyday for decades now.

This is probably how LLM can extrapolate all the things they "know" from human generated text: their tokens reflect the human behavior determinism a its fullest expression

(hence at more data for training, much better/closer their behavior ressemble the human behavior/ideas)

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by pnf on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:13PM (#34304949)
I can't agree with you although I can understand why you believe these things. Human instinct is, as I say, insufficiently-determined for survival. Is "free will" mostly an illusion? Or is it "fully deterministic"? If it is mostly then it is not "fully" determined. I'd be curious to hear how you think that can be and whether you make decisions in your own life or if you are resigned to your fate.

In any case, I'm not saying individual humans make many reasoned out decisions. Quite the opposite. Human individuals adopt a cultural second nature bequeathed to them by their heritage to avoid the necessity of making decisions. The culture over time adopts certain default decisions that are advantageous to survival. These are inculcated into the individual via their cultural conditioning. A baby has no culture and very few instincts (hunger, pleasure, pain, disgust). If you think humans are operating at the lower levels of instinct then why do they pursue or avoid certain behaviors that change over time? One answer is that they are responding to acceptable norms of behavior. As those norms change, they adapt and adopt. They change with the times, as the saying goes. A tiger can be trained to behave a certain way using stimulus/reward training but it doesn't self-regulate according to new norms. One could argue that elephants do this, if properly conditioned with a large stake early in life. But you could also make the case that elephants (like dolphins) are, like humans, self-conscious to a degree. I don't know if this is true, but it is an interesting thought. A more cynical person might say the elephant is not choosing anything but has been trained just like the tiger to avoid pain.

LLMs, or let us say AGI based on probabilistic models, can mimic behavior represented in its data and is very impressive at these language games and, with the right feedback, can correct some of its more glaring productions but it must ever be a parasite on human cultural production for it to gain what you call "knowledge". As a thought experiment, suppose we could set an LLM running on autopilot and send it into space with a feedback loop where it could add its productions to its source corpora. Is there any point in the future where it is generating new and coherent output? Or does it degenerate into raving madness?

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by nb3423 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:41PM (#34305209)
"I'd be curious to hear how you think that can be and whether you make decisions in your own life or if you are resigned to your fate."

haha just living life as usual, whatever internal stuff is feeding my main loop.

I left the deep thoughts to threads like this one and/or people more qualified.

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by pnf on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:49PM (#34305741)
Forgive the presumption, but I really think you should abandon that model of self understanding. Fatalism is a kind of disease that can be treated if caught early but is deadly if left undiagnosed. I don't believe you are really serious but I think it's important to not live hypocritically, which such a view makes unavoidable. But joking aside, one problem with thinking of your self as a kind of Javascript runtime is that it trivializes your life. Even if a computationalist model of mind were largely correct, which I don't believe, a life worth living would reject such a thing on principle, since to believe in it is to think of oneself as a philosophical zombie, which is a creature without consciousness, without will, condemned to infect others with its own nullity, treating brains as mere food rather than the seat of human uniqueness, unable to connect with others, or even notice others except as the motive objects of their ravenous impulses. Taken seriously to oneself, this attitude is a kind of spiritual suicide. I don't recommend.
Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by nb3423 on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:00AM (#34309028)
no biggy, thanks for your words, it's very much appreciated. I do live well, thinking about these things brings obviously some considerations, but ultimately I don't think about myself as a script, aside the technical considerations I also need to include a margin of error to these philosofical zombie hypothesis, and if there is 1% chance of error in it (which I think there should be a lot more, for there are lots of factors to be considered), I would be resigning my free will to a false assumption, so that's why I can't live under the assumption I have no free will.

Look at the history, many "definitive" hypothesis have been refuted along the centuries, when thinking about these I can just wonder how many people have lived their entire life under false premises, just because they were 100% sure "their" philosophy was the "definitive truth".

The truth in real life is a more fluid concept, it constantly changes with entropy (the main culprit if you go all the way down the reasons for change), so I can't take my hypothesis of human determinism as a definitive truth, neither live my life under that premise.

I'd recommend to anyone also to not live theirs thinking they cannot change their own fate.

Thanks again for your words, felt very touched.

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by pnf on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:46AM (#34309713)
That's nice to hear. I think you may end up surprised at how many of the certainties of life turn out, on inspection, to be full of qualifications. I can say that's been my experience. To quote Hamlet: "There are more things in Heaven and Earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy." Luckily, you don't have to find all the caveats yourself, there are plenty of eager pokers-of-balloons in the world who will gladly point out the flaws in arguments. All you have to do is cultivate a love of the counterargument and many philosophical and political certainties ebb and fade, uncovering very few, very precious leftovers, like a tide going out. Those remnants can't be lost, though, because they are a sort of foundation of your true self. They can be covered over or left to ruin but they're always there for some reason. Thanks for the exchange. Best of luck.
Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by nb3423 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:49PM (#34305288)
".. it must ever be a parasite on human cultural production for it to gain what you call "knowledge"

This thing goes way deep into AI theories, but probaly AGI and artificial beings self-consciusness are two different problems. I think when the second problem gets solved, the human cultural production would no longer be necessary to "create" new AI / AGIs.

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by pnf on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:19PM (#34305523)
Yes, I think that is one idea. But without true symbolism, where is the ground of understanding that would allow for synthetic generation going to come from? Right now, it has to be added by human coaches and means nothing to the model. Personally, I'm not confident we're anywhere near solving for artificial self-consciousness. Heck, we don't even understand human consciousness. But forever is a long time. I'm both impressed and unimpressed by the current LLM models. They will get better at what they do, I'm confident of that. But it does seem there's built-in limitation that can't be solved with this approach. It will be interesting, for instance, if logic gates can be encoded in a neural net architecture. That could allow them to reason the way a computer using a formal language today might. In that future, the language models are massively effective parsers plus some layers enabling it to be "Turing complete".
Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by api on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:54AM (#34299101)
It wouldn’t be hard to inject nondeterminism into the neural network directly either.
Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by zmgsabst on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:16AM (#34299255)
Also, most AI (eg, chess AI) will pick randomly from a set of top moves — if there are several good options.

How random that is we can argue; but how random is your biology really?

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by evrydayhustling on Sunday January 08, 2023 @11:04AM (#34300187)
I think the authors' (flawed) bulwark to this would be that their notion of "agency" requires a system with a well defined boundary -- in other words essential entropy cannot come from outside the system. Section 3 spends a lot of words on this concept of agency and closure.

> The most central distinction to be made here is that the selection of a specific behavior is not purely reactive, not entirely determined by environmental conditions, but (at least partially) originates from and depends on the internal organization of the system making the selection.... [Agency] requires organizational closure .... Organisms, as autonomous agents, are Kantian wholes, i. e., organized beings with the property that the parts exist for and by means of the whole.

What's funny is that I can't imagine how a serious modern biologist signed off on any claims of closure for biological systems. Our own behavior arises out of a mess of genetics, epigenetics, symbiotic relationships, and other external feedback loops which intermingle the "agency" of many self-preserving and self-replicating systems, from transposons hijacking our genetic strands to gut biomes regulating our hormonal balances.

The history of biology is essentially one of humans drawing labels around supposed units, and nature making a mockery of those boundaries upon further research. Like other efforts before, this particular definition of closed agency is more a projection of our own psychology than an observation of the natural world.

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by mannykannot on Sunday January 08, 2023 @12:03PM (#34300795)
Indeed, and I think we can make a couple of specific responses to the passage you quote.

The first thing is that if selection of a specific behavior is determined by environmental together with the internal organization of the system making the selection, how is that not reactive, why would it matter if it isn't, and why does that not apply to robots?

The second point is that the internal organization of organisms is a result of evolution, so it too has been determined by the environment, and, furthermore, by a process that can be - and is - used to develop programs.

There are heavy doses of ontological argumentation here ("this is an X and that is a Y"), but our categories are determined by what we know (or think we do.) As you say, nature can make a mockery of those boundaries.

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by asplake on Sunday January 08, 2023 @01:45PM (#34301808)
I am not a biologist, but I have read Maturana and Varela (originators of autopoesis), and they are not that naive. If there’s anything they do understand, it is the co-development of things over time in mutual relationship, ie structural coupling.
Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by nb3423 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:16PM (#34304440)
But organic intelligence is by its nature - genetics - almost full deterministic, very few - if any - behaviors are left without being pre-ordered by their genetic constrains and/or the cultural environment resulted from those same genetic constrains.

Human for instance, are mostly "cognitive hamsters", running every day into their "cognitive wheels": incessantly - but for sleeping - looking for money, happiness, food, sex, etc. mostly a very short list of drives. No matter the year, the geolocation, the language they speak.

Re:How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits ... by Kim_Bruning on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:20PM (#34305018)
I can't say this is a strange argument, because it is not intuitive to many.

Entropy is mostly boring noise. What's really interesting is Chaos (the mathematical concept).

Things such as Turing machines, Cellular Automata (such as Conway's Game Of Life) and Actual Life are chaotic.

While Chaotic systems can be highly unpredictable, they are -in fact- deterministic.

For example -given the same seed- a Pseudo Random Number Generator will always give you the same sequence of pseudo-random numbers. But (for a good PRNG) if you give it some novel seed, you can't predict the sequence ahead of time; you have to actually run the PRNG to find out.

In real life, for a chaotic system like say -the weather on earth- , you're also going to have a hard time working backwards to find the original seed(s). Given a hurricane in the Carribean, good luck finding the original proverbial butterfly out of all the butterflies in China.

So in order to have an intelligent machine it actually needs to be highly deterministic. At the same time it will by necessity become rather unpredictable. This is not immediately intuitive. But that's basically what all the hullabaloo about Chaos Theory was actually about in a nutshell.