News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will We Know Alien Life When We See It? by Retric on Saturday January 07, 2023 @10:08PM (#34295617)
Sure, that belief isn’t backed up by existing evidence but it’s hardly worth rehashing again.

Anyway something more interesting you said was the belief that all life came from a single cell. It’s unclear if all life ever to exist on earth had cells or if they evolved later. Also, we can’t tell if life showed up independently fairly frequently but was out competed or just once.

This is somewhat dependent on how life is defined. Prions aren’t generally considered alive but would have shown up quite frequently due to random chance. The more complex self replicating matter must be to be considered alive the higher the hurdle for life to have formed randomly but the more likely for simpler self replicating matter to evolve into life. Yet, saying evolution of non living mater results in life seems to twist the meaning around unpleasantly.

Re:Will We Know Alien Life When We See It? by yarg on Saturday January 07, 2023 @10:38PM (#34295788)
Just once for the initial self-replicators would be my guess.

Not in a cell, but in porous rock around the hydrothermal vents (at the bottom of the ocean).

Given the exponentialish 'population' growth of chemical soup, coupled with the fact that the very low likelyhood of a localised self-replicator forming, by the time second place came about the game would already be over.

Far more likely is preserved 'mutations' to chemical replicators leading to divergent forms of demi-life.

Re:Will We Know Alien Life When We See It? by Retric on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:16AM (#34299254)
> by the time second place came about the game would already be over.

That’s presumably true, but it means there could have been a very large number of losers not just 1. Aka if extremely primitive life showed up once on earth then it might be a rare event, if it happened 100 trillion times then most planets with the right conditions will have some form of life.

Re:Will We Know Alien Life When We See It? by yarg on Sunday January 08, 2023 @03:30PM (#34302765)
It'll be a Poisson distribution.

If the spread is too wide then the chance of spatiotemporally cohabiting civilizations of distinct origins will be diminishingly small.

But I don't actually think that the planetary parameters that allow for replication are (in any way) specific to earth.

Re:Will We Know Alien Life When We See It? by alienalp on Saturday January 07, 2023 @10:36PM (#34295776)
Even if it doesn't define life obviously replication is the thing here. Without capability of replication there is no continuation and even if some matter is alive it has limited time to obtain this ability. Which is actually seems like slightly more possible than impossible to me. Not saying straightforward impossible just because we exist.
Re:Will We Know Alien Life When We See It? by yarg on Saturday January 07, 2023 @10:43PM (#34295818)
Any non infinitessimal probability leads to certainty given enough time.

Consider it in terms of reactions per second - take the likelyhood of non-formation of replicators (call it 99.999999999% - because it actually does not matter), to the power of the number of reactors, to the power of the number of seconds since the universe began.

The likelyhood that no self-replicators form rapidly plummets to a vanishing value.

Re:Will We Know Alien Life When We See It? by moloch-hai on Sunday January 08, 2023 @04:21PM (#34303269)
By that standard there hasn't been much time.
Re:Will We Know Alien Life When We See It? by yarg on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:37PM (#34304636)
I may have added too many nines, but the point stands.