News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Skeptical Take on ChatGPT: Ezra Klein Interviews Gary M... by carrolldunham on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:05PM (#34284711)
>"It doesn't 'really know'..."

You write this out as if this is an idea you formed yourself and not a tired/expired talking point - it's such a funny comment because it's pure regurgitation, but the argument in it is against regurgitation being "real thought". So are you a bot? Or are you intending to actually proving that there's no difference between ML and 'real' intelligence by showing you do what ML does? Mind spinning stuff

Re:A Skeptical Take on ChatGPT: Ezra Klein Interviews Gary M... by cwalv on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:15PM (#34285133)
> it's such a funny comment because it's pure regurgitation, but the argument in it is against regurgitation being "real thought"

If I understand based on my own experience of 'consciousness' that "I" exist, even if everything else I perceive is a simulation or poorly encoded representation of reality, is that understanding 'regurgitation'?

Re:A Skeptical Take on ChatGPT: Ezra Klein Interviews Gary M... by mensetmanusman on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:18PM (#34285150)
And you write this out as if this is an idea you formed yourself and not a tired/expired talking point…

See, it’s turtles all the way down :)

Re:A Skeptical Take on ChatGPT: Ezra Klein Interviews Gary M... by chazzyluc on Saturday January 07, 2023 @02:42AM (#34286078)
Yeah, I was paraphrasing the interview and then going into more detail on why I thought it was interesting in the sentences after the one you stopped reading on.

Honestly, I was kinda hoping to hear some better constructed and well reasoned insights & counter points beyond your “regurgitated mind swill” hot take but I guess that’s on me for not managing expectations.

Ah well, I usually comment once a year or so and then get immediately reminded why I stay off HN. See y’all in 2024!