News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It Takes 6k Gallons of Water to Cool the World’s Fastest ... by areoform on Friday January 06, 2023 @06:06PM (#34282656)
Politely, this computer exists because the DoE performs stockpile stewardship.

Less politely, it exists because of The Bombs. Everything else it will do is a hobby. It is specifically designed for whatever compute needs their classified program has.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockpile_stewardship

https://www.energy.gov/nnsa/articles/stockpile-stewardship-a...

All of this capital is being spent because the test ban treaty prohibits the detonation of these weapons, but the US stockpile and its efficacy must be maintained and new weapons must be designed. So how do you know if an old weapon or a new design will work or not?

Some part of the answer is real data + simulations. Lots and lots of simulations. It's why Frontier exists and why the DoE has pursued exascale compute for quite some time.

(as for the real data part, it's why places like the National Ignition Factory exist, and why there's an active experimental program that exists to study dummy warheads in unexpected ways, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYdAT0v4DHs )

Re:It Takes 6k Gallons of Water to Cool the World’s Fastest ... by gh02t on Friday January 06, 2023 @06:37PM (#34282958)
This is really not true, the stockpile stewardship thing is a separate part of DoE and Frontier does no nuclear weapons-related simulations at all. Frontier is things like materials research, nuclear reactor simulations, machine learning etc. DoE is building (and has) built similar leadership-class computers for stockpile stewardship but it's a completely separate program.
Re:It Takes 6k Gallons of Water to Cool the World’s Fastest ... by watersb on Friday January 06, 2023 @07:04PM (#34283239)
Another big application is drug discovery and development, computational chemistry.

I don't believe that Frontier was used directly for COVID vaccine research, but it very well could have done.

Re:It Takes 6k Gallons of Water to Cool the World’s Fastest ... by gh02t on Friday January 06, 2023 @07:13PM (#34283331)
It's on the schedule for Frontier, which is still coming online. Summit (its predecessor) was, however.
Re:It Takes 6k Gallons of Water to Cool the World’s Fastest ... by areoform on Friday January 06, 2023 @07:13PM (#34283329)
I am unsure how tangled the relationships are as what you're saying can be strictly true, but I doubt that this has nothing to do with weapons related simulation.

Here's the most recent report to congress, published in March 2022 about the Stockpile Stewardship and Management Plan,

    Near-Term and Out-Year Mission Goals:
        ◼ Advance the innovative experimental platforms, diagnostic equipment, and computational capabilities necessary to ensure stockpile safety, security, reliability, and effectiveness:
        – Achieve exascale computing by delivering an exascale-capable machine and modernizing the nuclear weapons code base
        – Develop an operational enhanced capability (advanced radiography and reactivity measurements) for subcritical experiments
        – Quantify the effects of plutonium aging on weapon performance over time
        – Assure an enduring, trusted supply of strategic radiation-hardened microsystems
and,

    The weapons comprising the U.S. nuclear stockpile are assessed to be safe, reliable, effective, and secure. DOE/NNSA’s scientific infrastructure is currently adequate to support stockpile actions. The DOE/NNSA plans to address near-term gaps in required scientific capabilities by deploying the DOE/NNSA’s first exascale computing platform in fiscal year (FY)2023 and by improving capabilities to conduct subcritical experiments through the Enhanced Capabilities for Subcritical Experiments project by FY 2026.
It seems they're building three of these computers, Frontier is one of them, from the budget requests and a press release,

    The budget request for Advanced Simulation and Computing increased to support pursuing new validated integrated design codes and advanced high-performance computing capabilities, including the El Capitan exascale system procurement.
The press release,

    Featuring advanced capabilities for modeling, simulation and artificial intelligence (AI), based on Cray’s new Shasta architecture, El Capitan is projected to run national nuclear security applications at more than 50 times the speed of LLNL’s Sequoia system. Depending on the application, El Capitan will run roughly 10 times faster on average than LLNL’s Sierra system, currently the world’s second most powerful supercomputer at 125 petaflops of peak performance. Projected to be at least four times more energy efficient than Sierra, El Capitan is expected to go into production by late 2023, servicing the needs of NNSA’s Tri-Laboratory community: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Los Alamos National Laboratory and Sandia National Laboratories
             
    El Capitan will be DOE’s third exascale-class supercomputer, following Argonne National Laboratory’s "Aurora" and Oak Ridge National Laboratory’s "Frontier" system. All three DOE exascale supercomputers will be built by Cray utilizing their Shasta architecture, Slingshot interconnect and new software platform.  
Link to the congressional report, https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-03/FY%202022...

Link to the press release, https://www.llnl.gov/news/doennsa-lab-announce-partnership-c...

-

It does seem to me that it's an accurate assessment to say that this project exists because of the nuclear weapons research mandate.

Re:It Takes 6k Gallons of Water to Cool the World’s Fastest ... by gh02t on Friday January 06, 2023 @07:29PM (#34283461)
> It does seem to me that it's an accurate assessment to say that this project exists because of the nuclear weapons research mandate.

It's not an accurate assessment, it's an over-simplification. DoE does weapons research. DoE also does general science research. They are separate responsibilities and have to be, because weapons research is classified and is legally required to be kept separate. The funding pathway that pays for the computing needs of each mission likewise is legally separate. The computers are housed, as noted by your quoted press release, in separate laboratories. Those laboratories are run independently of each other, and have distinct responsibilities. Frontier cannot run weapons-related simulations because it's not approved for classified work, which has some really strenuous requirements that the government takes extremely seriously.

It is true to say DoE exists because of nuclear weapons research, that's a big part of their role and history. The distinction is that it's not their only role, and their general science mission is not purely in service of the weapons program legally or practically. It's true to say that the programs coexist together and operate in parallel, but they are separate with their own goals. You're citing the goals of the NNSA computing program, which absolutely are weapons-related, but the Office of Science that funds and operates Frontier, Aurora etc is a separate entity with independent funding and governance within DoE.

Re:It Takes 6k Gallons of Water to Cool the World’s Fastest ... by areoform on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:38PM (#34284080)
I appreciate your points, and objectively you are right. I think the place where we are diverging are in how we slice the history/pie. At this point, at least for me, our discussion is becoming extremely interesting and I'm thinking/learning more in the process.

Would you mind humoring me?

—

For me, this is the fruit of a tree and a part of a long chain of causality. We start with von Neumann fiddling with machines at Los Alamos and wind up at the Accelerated Strategic Computing Initiative from the 90s https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK44974/ and then fast forward to the excascale program in the early-to-mid 2010s.

I am not a professional, but this is an area of interest for me. And I've been tracking it for some time, and in the earlier communications, the ORNL etc seemed to be fairly clear on who was cutting the checks, from 2013,

     The Department of Energy’s (DOE) Office of Science and the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) have awarded $25.4 million in research and development contracts to five leading companies in high-performance computing (HPC) to accelerate the development of next-generation supercomputers. 
     
     Under DOE’s new DesignForward initiative, AMD, Cray, IBM, Intel Federal and NVIDIA will work to advance extreme-scale, on the path to exascale, computing technology that is vital to national security, scientific research, energy security and the nation's economic competitiveness.
    
    “Exascale computing is key to NNSA’s capability of ensuring the safety and security of our nuclear stockpile without returning to underground testing,” said Robert Meisner, director of the NNSA Office of Advanced Simulation and Computing program. “The resulting simulation capabilities will also serve as valuable tools to address nonproliferation and counterterrorism issues, as well as informing other national security decisions.”
From: https://www.nersc.gov/news-publications/nersc-news/nersc-cen...

The program was funded fully in 2016 after many years of partial funding, ORNL's report,

    The mission of the Exascale Computing Project (ECP) is the accelerated delivery of a capable exascale computing ecosystem to provide breakthrough solutions addressing our most critical challenges in scientific discovery, energy assurance, economic competitiveness, and national security.

    As a multi-lab effort, sponsored by the DOE’s Office of Science and National Nuclear Security Administration, the ECP is chartered with the following tasks:

         Developing exascale-ready applications and solutions that address currently intractable problems of strategic importance and national interest.
         Creating and deploying an expanded and vertically integrated software stack on DOE HPC pre-exascale and exascale systems.
         Delivering US HPC vendor technology advances and deploying ECP products to DOE HPC pre-exascale and exascale systems.
         Delivering exascale simulation and data science innovations and solutions to national problems that enhance US economic competitiveness, change our quality of life, and strengthen our national security.
From: https://www.ornl.gov/content/about-ecp

I think the other applications are far more important than the weapons research, fwiw. Just as ARPA-net and the internet it spawned ended up being far more valuable than their initial strategic use case. Even if the important stuff is a side project, just like fusion as an eventual source of energy seems to be for NIF, it's great that it's happening at all.

Hope this makes sense!

Thanks!

Re:It Takes 6k Gallons of Water to Cool the World’s Fastest ... by gh02t on Saturday January 07, 2023 @11:04AM (#34289306)
NNSA does pay into the broader ECP (which refers to the whole supercomputer program not just Frontier) but they aren't the only contributor. Like I said, DoE does build supercomputers for stockpile maintenance missions. Those computers will be built with basically all NNSA money and probably little to no Office of Science money. AFAIK some amount of NNSA money went into building Frontier specifically but it was earmarked under their non-stockpile missions. NNSA doesn't only design/build/maintain weapons they also are responsible for nuclear security missions. For example, they provide the R&D that backs US support to the IAEA. They are funding a limited amount of unclassified, non-weapons work being done on Frontier in support of their other missions. The key point is that stockpile maintenance is firewalled, both in terms of funding and operations, from the other stuff and they are not the only contributor.

DoE has always been a "big tent" of separate missions and I totally understand how it gets confusing. Its predecessor the AEC also had a weird mix of practically orthogonal goals. The non-weapons and non-nuclear missions have gotten a lot bigger in the last 30-40 years and are more or less operated independently of each other. NNSA is also functionally an independent agency within DoE, but it's important to note that they do fund pure science work too, with non-weapons related goals.

Re:It Takes 6k Gallons of Water to Cool the World’s Fastest ... by ballen on Friday January 06, 2023 @06:38PM (#34282966)
Believe you’re thinking of the HPC facilities at LLNL and LANL. Frontier is run under DOE ASCR as one of the Leadership Computing Facilities (LCF), which focus mainly on open science use cases. Most of the compute hours in the LCFs is allocated via DOE INCITE and ALCC programs.