Re:Caloric restriction increases lifespan but affects brain ...
by torstenvl on Friday January 06, 2023 @06:24AM
(#34273529)
I read Cory Doctorow's Eastern Standard Tribe almost 20 years ago and have forgotten most of it, but I vividly remember the beginning when the main character is contemplating giving himself a lobotomy, trying to decide whether to be smart or happy.
I think it's a bit of a false dichotomy though. I've seen people in cognitive decline, and they are never happy. They're frustrated at not knowing what they used to know, not understanding new things, not remembering important information, forgetting loved ones. Some can handle it with grace ("I don't know your name, but I know that I love you.") but many cannot. And in the later stages, it becomes miserable: forgetting where you are, being terrified constantly, and reliving the grief of losing people over and over and over again. (My great grandmother asking in a panic, "Where's Nancy?," my grandmother who predeceased her, at every family gathering.)
I don't know if calorie-restriction brain integrity loss presents the same as age-related dementia, but I'm emphatically uninterested in finding out first hand.
I think it's a bit of a false dichotomy though. I've seen people in cognitive decline, and they are never happy. They're frustrated at not knowing what they used to know, not understanding new things, not remembering important information, forgetting loved ones. Some can handle it with grace ("I don't know your name, but I know that I love you.") but many cannot. And in the later stages, it becomes miserable: forgetting where you are, being terrified constantly, and reliving the grief of losing people over and over and over again. (My great grandmother asking in a panic, "Where's Nancy?," my grandmother who predeceased her, at every family gathering.)
I don't know if calorie-restriction brain integrity loss presents the same as age-related dementia, but I'm emphatically uninterested in finding out first hand.