Re:C++ vs. Rust Build Times
by scaredginger on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:21AM
(#34273069)
What you've said here is mostly correct. The key part you've omitted is that monomorphization is opt-in. One could write Rust like C if they wanted to; they would have to be insane, but they could
“opt-in” in the sense that I could just multiple versions of my functions if I want to? Agreed!
Re:C++ vs. Rust Build Times
by scaredginger on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:11PM
(#34285112)
Yeah, or accept a small runtime cost in exchange for a smaller binary
If you do the same in rust, you need access to the module's implementation for monomorphization. You might skip the type checking of a function of the implementation or even cache the generated code for a monomorphization as optimizations, but generally you have to treat every function as often as it is used. So the best rust could do is akin to C++ precompiled headers whereas a language like OCaml can simply compile every module exactly once.
Note: OCaml pays for this elegance. Its uniform object representation is less efficient than what rust does. It's a trade-off that the rust designers consciously made, I think.