News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by tptacek on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @07:07PM (#3426615)
Google already states its intention to tune its SERPs so that they answer the questions users likely intend to pose when they type a search in. Google is already in the business of judging search intent.

The "dangerous precedent" you're talking about was set by the Google web spam team a long time ago.

Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by patio11 on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @07:57PM (#3426767)
The "dangerous precedent" you're talking about was set by the Google web spam team a long time ago.

Yep. If you wanted to look at one particular event, several years ago a major Nazi site ranked #1 for [Jew], because the people who care about [Jew] and were early adopters on the Internet happened to be Nazis. Google, at the time, refused to hand-edit that, and instead put PSA AdWords ads against the SERP for [Jew] saying "While we're certainly not Nazis, the algorithm decrees that the most relevant result for this search is, regrettably, a Nazi site." [Edit to add: Wow, the page did not linkrot: http://www.google.com/explanation.html ]This was a deeply controversial result internally and externally at the time.

Google 2012 is not Google 2002. Results which would get mentioned on the nightly news get fixed, period.

Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by moultano on Thursday January 05, 2012 @01:29AM (#3427701)
Google 2012 is not Google 2002. Results which would get mentioned on the nightly news get fixed, period.

I disagree. We certainly like to fix bad results, but not manually. There's a very narrow range of things Google is willing to do manually in search. One of them is taking action on sites that are found to have violated the webmaster guidelines, but banning a result from a query just because it's embarrassing isn't something we do.

For instance, in that example you cite, jewwatch.com is still at number 2 for [jew].

Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by tptacek on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @08:09PM (#3426801)
I concede immediately that I'm oversimplifying the issue. Google doesn't keep the "problem" Santorum result at the top of the SERP simply because they don't like Rick Santorum.

They're also (perhaps mostly) doing it to keep themselves out of the news, since the prevailing meme about that SERP now is "oh well, that's how the Internet works" and the result of a manual intervention would be a flood of news stories about an intervention Google probably doesn't want everyone knowing they do regularly.

Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by jaggederest on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @08:17PM (#3426826)
It still ranks 3rd for the term 'jew', right after 'jew watch', which I assume is a hate site.
Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by drivebyacct2 on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @11:00PM (#3427325)
>Results which would get mentioned on the nightly news get fixed, period.

I can't think of a single publication or media outlet that hasn't covered Santorum's "Google problem".

Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by rat87 on Thursday January 05, 2012 @12:31AM (#3427543)
I'm not sure whether he is right ,but I think that's his point(ie he believes that most similar problems get special tweaking and Santorum doeesn't for whatever reason)
Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by burgerbrain on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @08:03PM (#3426777)
Well, I (of course) cannot speak for the general google using population, but the few times I have ever googled santorum it has been to show people the gag results.
Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by veidr on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @09:56PM (#3427129)
That's the only reason anybody I know that has ever googled "Santorum" also.

And seriously, given that The Daily Show has pumped this gag several times (the Mitt Romney v. Santorum chocolate box thing last night being the latest), with its millions and millions of viewers, to say nothing of all the other publicity that this gag has gotten, I think it's reasonable to say that this "gag" -- the collective redefinition of the word Santorum in response to perceived bigotry -- is actually a bigger deal than Rick Santorum the (fringey, extreme, minor) Republican politician.

That would likely change if Santorum actually began to be a plausible contender for the presidential nomination, but that's extremely unlikely.

I think the maximum response from Google appropriate to this issue would be one of those explanatory disclaimers in the sidebar, like they put next to the photoshopped gorilla photo results when you image-searched for Michelle Obama.

Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by yahelc on Thursday January 05, 2012 @12:15AM (#3427502)
You might want to read up on the developments of the last 24 hours.

Santorum has gone from being a fringe minor candidate to being the last conservative standard bearer with a shot. It may be temporary, but he lost the Iowa caucus by 8 votes (ie, essentially tied it).

Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by veidr on Thursday January 05, 2012 @02:44AM (#3427866)
I do know about the Iowa caucus outcome, but I don't think it says much about Santorum's chance of becoming the Republican party nominee.

Now if Santorum somehow went on to win, or even do well, in South Carolina, New Hampshire, Florida, and then several more states, then I'd be proved incorrect and at that point Mr. Santorum would probably be a bigger deal than grody-substance santorum. And, perhaps, Google's top search result might even organically change. But that's still exceedingly unlikely.

Not that I place too much stock in arbitrary futures markets, especially with regard to democratically-conducted elections, but Intrade's numbers are historically more predictive than what Iowa's ~120,000 Republican caucus-goers choose:

http://www.intrade.com/v4/markets/contract/?contractId=69090...

Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by ams6110 on Thursday January 05, 2012 @12:53AM (#3427612)
In 1980, Reagan, the conservative, narrowly lost Iowa to George H. W. Bush, the "establishment" Republican.
Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by lukev on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @07:54PM (#3426756)
Algorithmically, sure, that's their goal. Manual intervention is another kettle of fish entirely.
Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by wglb on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @10:35PM (#3427238)
So that leads to the question of why Bing is giving similar results.
Re:How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse by tptacek on Thursday January 05, 2012 @01:03AM (#3427639)
I'm not disputing the fact that the "problem" link landed at the top of [santorum] organically and algorithmically. Of course it did. Google didn't stick it at the top of the SERP.

But Google does police SERPs for shenanigans like this, and is deliberately not touching this one (for any of a variety of reasons, most of them not ideological).

All it takes is for Bing to be a little more lax about policing its SERPs for it to have the same result.