Re:The Expanding Dark Forest and Generative AI
by pixl97 on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @04:05PM
(#34251595)
Again this gets particularly messy.
With oil there is very strong chain of possession. I can't copy your raw oil at little to no cost, and for the most part the next barrel of oil I pump out of the ground is not made of pieces of the past barrel of oil I pumped out of the ground. Each barrel of oil is a wholly separate entity. If I make all past oil disappear, you still have your barrel.
Information is not like that at all. It is far more often a continuum of large bits of the past with small changes that redefine it's usage. If I took all bits of past knowledge out of your IP set, you'd be left with something useless in incomplete in almost every case. Trying to treat IP like a physical artifact leads to a multitude of failures.
With oil there is very strong chain of possession. I can't copy your raw oil at little to no cost, and for the most part the next barrel of oil I pump out of the ground is not made of pieces of the past barrel of oil I pumped out of the ground. Each barrel of oil is a wholly separate entity. If I make all past oil disappear, you still have your barrel.
Information is not like that at all. It is far more often a continuum of large bits of the past with small changes that redefine it's usage. If I took all bits of past knowledge out of your IP set, you'd be left with something useless in incomplete in almost every case. Trying to treat IP like a physical artifact leads to a multitude of failures.