News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Secure Dropbox alternatives? by rdl on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @08:30AM (#3424001)
There are other services which advertise security, but nothing where you actually are likely to audit the code. Even if their security model is better than what Dropbox is now using, you have to factor in availability issues (Dropbox seems more solid as a business than a lot of the others), functionality, etc. You also need to trust the entire development process, release engineering, and knowing your binaries correspond to the source code. It's not easy.

There is a slight benefit to "must ship trojaned software to recover passphase, then decrypt" vs. "just access data server-side", but in practice, if your threat is the government, there's not a huge difference. If your threat is a server break-in by a third party, then there's some difference.

Overall, probably the best bet, if you don't run your own servers, is Dropbox plus your choice of well tested encryption on top. As for your best well-tested encryption, that's a hard problem too -- Truecrypt has a pretty wide following and some versions have been audited, and source is published. For general purpose use on Macs, I just use Apple's encryption -- it's probably ok, but as far as I know, hasn't really been analyzed by third parties (I'd be happy to NDA and look at it). I rationalize it as if Apple is subverted, and I use OSX, I'm fucked even if third party disk encryption software itself is safe.

Re:Ask HN: Secure Dropbox alternatives? by makaio on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @09:21AM (#3424198)
After reviewing the options some time ago, I ended up using encfs on top of Dropbox. You still mount and unmount it like Truecrypt or Apple's encrypted disk images, but behind the scenes instead of creating an opaque block device to store the files, the individual files and directories are stored with their names and contents encrypted. I like this method because individual files can be synced (which is the whole purpose of Dropbox), safe syncing does not require unmounting the volume, it can be mounted on multiple computers at the same time, is cross-platfrom, and I think it should be possible to revert individual files to a previous revision (though I've never tried). The main disadvantage, from a security perspective, is that the existence of and approximate size of your files can be easily determined without decrypting. This does not matter for my purposes, but might for some. It is also slightly more complicated to set up, although if you've ever mounted a filesystem from the command line in Unix you should have no problem.

Here is a nice overview of its use on OS X: http://www.packetslave.com/2011/04/21/dropbox-encryption-w-e...

Re:Ask HN: Secure Dropbox alternatives? by nuttendorfer on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @08:42AM (#3424037)
Is it possible to use Truecrypt in Dropbox without issues?
Re:Ask HN: Secure Dropbox alternatives? by michaelcampbell on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @09:01AM (#3424110)
Sure. But you remove the benefit of syncing small diffs; you pretty much have to sync the entire truecrypt volume.
Re:Ask HN: Secure Dropbox alternatives? by joev on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @09:30AM (#3424227)
My (former) home network backup solution had a truecrypt volume created locally, and rsync'ed to my offsite backup provider (rsync.net). It did not have to send the entire volume for small diffs; in my experience, Truecrypt keeps local changes local in the volume.
Re:Ask HN: Secure Dropbox alternatives? by michaelcampbell on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @05:32PM (#3426237)
That's a good point; thanks. I'm not sure if Dropbox diffs at sub-file level - perhaps it does.

The short story is that Dropbox + Truecrypt work fine, but may not (or may!) be optimal.

Re:Ask HN: Secure Dropbox alternatives? by mike-cardwell on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @09:04AM (#3424124)
I use encfs with Dropbox because each file is encrypted separately, rather than a single monolithic container.
Re:Ask HN: Secure Dropbox alternatives? by csh on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @09:02AM (#3424115)
Possible, but inconvenient because the whole volume will get synchronized every time you modify a file.