The subscription service was as much of a joke. Sure, it sounds great to be able to access a huge library for a low monthly fee, but guess what, if you don't pay that monthly fee...forever...you won't have access to any of your favorite music. A track on iTunes is $0.99. A track on the Zune subscription service was $∞.00.
Though as an interesting PS, the Zune Pass offers (offered?) 10 free permanent downloads every month. So, at 99c a track, you'd more or less make your subscription fee back.
The subscription model is the modern equivalent of the Columbia Music House. They'll send you music relentlessly even when you don't want it, only in this case if you cancel it all goes away and you've got nothing to show for it.
You'd have to be diligent to use those ten free downloads a month. You can't bank them, can you?
This is a ridiculous comparison. Do you pay for Netflix? Hulu Plus? Cable? Internet access? These are all subscription services.
Does it cost you infinite money to read Hacker News? Or to watch "Frasier" on cable or Netflix? Of course not. Zune Pass doesn't cost infinite money, either.
Columbia House was (is?) very nearly the opposite of a subscription. You paid for a crappy CD every month. You owned it. You didn't get inclusive access to a catalog.
Name 3 music subscription services that have 90+% overlap in their catalogs.
iTunes' hitherto expansion in scope has been amusing / scary. I noticed that the iOS app collection got saved in a subdirectory of ~/Music/ :)
I hope, for everyone's sake, that the Windows Phone market is bigger than just the handful of people who bought Zunes.
We've come so far since then!
Let me take you back to 2006. iPods were still using the classic click wheel. iTunes was horribly slow on a PC. Microsoft comes out with a competitor that has a simple up/down/left/right directional pad, and software that looks stunning and runs better on a PC. Many weren't sold on the idea. Many of those who were, however, loved it. Killer feature: the Zune Pass. All-you-can-eat from a huge library, fully integrated, syncs over wifi right to your player.
Time passes, and PMPs are a thing of the past. It's about phones now. You can either go back to using the iPod via the iPhone (and back to iTunes) and lose the Zune Pass, or to Android during its early, rough years. Still losing the Zune Pass, and having no centralized music manager. Then Microsoft comes along with a Zune phone, killer interface, Office, and Xbox Live to boot. I kept using my Zune right up to the point when I got a Windows Phone.
Microsoft is making some slam dunks recently, but the people and the press were, for a long time, unwilling to get burned again (understandably). Problem is, now the press has changed their tune but the people haven't. The Zune was a killer PMP, and now I can have it in phone form. For others, it's not so much that but the idea of not needing iTunes. That's major.
Now that I feel like a dirty shill, I'm going to go take a shower.