I've asked some "pointed questions" and been downvoted. What I learned from this is that while some discussion threads are about questioning and learning, others are about something else... I'm not sure what exactly... Hearing what you want to hear? Maybe someone else can provide some insight.
If your "pointed question" doesn't sound nice enough, the community will punish you for it. There are also a couple sacred cows that you would be well-advised against questioning.
Is there a list somewhere? We could learn a lot about our silent assumptions and possible limitations arising from it.
This struck a chord with me as well, and reminded me of pg's 'How to Disagree': http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html
Form is important too:
11. Watch your style, capitalize, proofread.
12. Avoid inside jokes, mannerisms, memes. Write for everyone, your readers may include people with very different background.
I initially interpreted that as "and other news aggregates like HN out there?" Oh, my silly brain...
But seriously, are there any other awesome news aggregates that I should be aware of?
"3. Be positive.
"This can really be hard when smart people debate, but try it anyway. Notice the difference between:
"Person A: Water is dry.
"Person B: No it's not. You're full of shit.
"and
"Person C: Water is dry.
"Person D: Not in my experience. What data have you encountered to cause you to arrive at that conclusion?"
I really like those "what data have you encountered" questions. In a lot of threads, I silently upvote replies that ask people making striking, unusual, bold, or implausible claims to please provide more information. (Too many of those helpful questions, alas, never get answers. But I'll keep on upvoting follow-up questions looking for facts when I see them.)
The author finishes his list of good suggestions with
"10. No list is ever exhaustive, on Hacker News or anywhere else. Anyone have any more suggestions?"
I'd be delighted to hear other suggestions about constructive participation on Hacker News too.