News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pop2Piano: Pop Audio-Based Piano Cover Generation by pimlottc on Sunday January 01, 2023 @12:43PM (#34208608)
This is pretty neat, but are they actually playable by a single human pianist? There's parts of the demo video where there are 10 simultaneous notes being played over 4 octaves, which doesn't seem humanly possible. Identifying the notes and chords being played is a big step but you've also got to adapt to the limitations of the instrument and figure out how to simplify it to be playable while retaining the same essence. That's a big part of what makes arrangement difficult.
Re:Pop2Piano: Pop Audio-Based Piano Cover Generation by cjhanks on Sunday January 01, 2023 @01:20PM (#34209012)
I didn't see catch this part, but having 10 notes over 4 octaves is not out of the question. If all of those notes are rhythmic, that could be a challenge. All of the fairly wide chords I saw could be played either with sustain or could be easily substituted with spread chords.

Pop pianists don't usually play what's exactly on the page.

Re:Pop2Piano: Pop Audio-Based Piano Cover Generation by alar44 on Sunday January 01, 2023 @02:30PM (#34209848)
As a piano player, yes.

However, the rhythms and chord selections are extremely weird and no human would ever play this way.

It's a cute toy, but is pretty far from actual piano comping. It doesn't sound human or natural at all.