I don't know who you are, I don't have anything against you, and I haven't voted either way on your main comment, but I really don't think such name-calling and vitriol are appropriate or have any place in a community I would want to be a part of. I don't think such comments add to the discussion, or are in line with the guidelines linked in the site's footer. So I've voted according.
Hopefully that helps explain where some of the down-votes are coming from.
Why a MOD? Because only a small fraction of the users can downvote, and users instead of the MOD attacking me personally write rebuttals. So far I have not a single rebuttal to any of the content of my original post. I did a great service to some lost CS profs -- outlined for them how to publish and, then, got attacked by a MOD.
Then I defended myself. You found my defense offensive. It was, but not nearly as much as that of the attack of the MOD.
And the situation and the attacks really SUCK, much more than anything I've written.
How do you know it's a mod? couldn't it just as easily be a random HN user who has enough karma to downvote?
My original post was a nice contribution to CS people having trouble getting published. But, if people don't like such a contribution, then they won't have it. So, I deleted it. It's gone. The CS profs can continue to struggle to publish without my help.
It's become clear that HN is PG's PC sandbox.
"The CS profs can continue to struggle to publish without my help."
This is emblematic of what I find grating in your writing style (and why I downvoted the parent post). In a single sentence you have managed to communicate (intentionally or otherwise) a sense of hubris and entitlement.
I used to help out HN by going to the new page and flagging what I thought was off topic content. My reward for this was to have my flagging privliges taken away :)
The unfortunate reality is that when you are a mod it's far easier to punish than it is to educate, especially when you're a volunteer.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3421033
early in the article was that the 'community' had a "serious problem" which was getting published. So I outlined how to get published, and that should have been a welcome contribution.
It wasn't very clear in the article if the article was mostly about the community or the 'problems' of the community. Whatever, I gave a solution to what seemed in the article to be the most important "problem" of the community.
But my solution wasn't welcome, so I deleted it. CS profs can struggle on their own to get published without my help.
PG: I'm being personally attacked by your mods again. This is a HN scandal.