News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kagi – Paid Search Engine by brookst on Thursday December 29, 2022 @11:46PM (#34181888)
I don’t think the argument is that “paid” is more private than “free” in a general sense, just that Kagi specifically can allow you more privacy than Google because Kati’s business model is direct monetization.

No need to argue the abstract; all that matters is the specific. If Kagi specifically is abusing trust, I’d love to hear it.

Re:Kagi – Paid Search Engine by philwelch on Friday December 30, 2022 @03:53AM (#34183251)
If you have to pay to use Kagi, that means you can only use it logged into a user profile that's associated with a payment method. Which means you have to trust them not to log your traffic in a way that can be associated back to your account. I would feel a little more comfortable if they had a warrant canary, but I can't seem to find one.

If Kagi is being honest, typical usage of Kagi is probably more private than typical usage of advertising-supported search engines. But I can more easily verify that using e.g. Brave Search via Tor is private.

Re:Kagi – Paid Search Engine by adalacelove on Friday December 30, 2022 @05:47AM (#34183835)
> If you have to pay to use Kagi, that means you can only use it logged into a user profile that's associated with a payment method.

True. But even the payment thing could be solved although most users won't care. Mullvad comes to mind: you can send them cash via mail and the payment is associated to a serial number that is simultaneously your login and password.

Re:Kagi – Paid Search Engine by kelnos on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:29PM (#34188944)
> If Kagi specifically is abusing trust, I’d love to hear it.

That's not really the point. It is up to Kagi to prove to their customers that they are trustworthy, not up to the customers to find abuses of trust.

If I -- for example -- use Tor and a private browsing window to access Google search, I have a pretty good expectation of privacy. I don't have to trust Google here; they simply cannot correlate my search with my Google account in this case, at least not 100% reliably (browser fingerprinting, etc.).

But with Kagi, they know that every search I make, regardless of how I make it, is from me (or, at least, from someone using my account), and that account is tied to my real-world identity. Sure, they could implement a more complicated payment method, where I pay a third party, and that third party blind-signs some credentials that Kagi trusts. But they haven't done that, at least as an option, and that bothers me.

When it comes to third parties, the best kind of trust is the trust that you don't have to have. I have to trust that Kagi isn't keeping a record of my search results. I would rather that I just don't have to trust anything, because there's nothing nefarious they can do.

Re:Kagi – Paid Search Engine by brookst on Friday December 30, 2022 @03:34PM (#34189755)
> It is up to Kagi to prove to their customers that they are trustworthy

Fair enough. Since that is a provably impossible bar, you’re basically saying nobody should do business with anyone. Which I admire from an ideological purity perspective, but don’t really have time for at this age.