Re:Tell HN: It's easier and faster to pirate an e-book, than...
by richardatlarge on Thursday December 29, 2022 @06:14PM
(#34179397)
Not so simple; how many times have I been told by someone they won’t buy my book, they’ll check it out from the library. This is not theft or piracy, but it’s taking the total value of something without compensation to the creator
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tell HN: It's easier and faster to pirate an e-book, than...
by throw10920 on Thursday December 29, 2022 @11:36PM
(#34181830)
This is absurd. Libraries are a legal construct that artists accept in order to provide a tradeoff between profit and benefit to society, the library still purchases copies of the work, and as those copies wear out over time and new ones need to be purchase, an individual is still indirectly and effectively paying a small amount to the artist (although, again, even if they weren't it wouldn't matter, because the creator agreed to the terms of the library, unlike with digital theft). They're not remotely comparable to piracy.
Re:Tell HN: It's easier and faster to pirate an e-book, than...
by josephcsible on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:36AM
(#34182171)
> the creator agreed to the terms of the library
Really? When/where?
Re:Tell HN: It's easier and faster to pirate an e-book, than...
by Popeyes on Friday December 30, 2022 @06:09AM
(#34183981)
Check your contracts with the publisher of your book.
Re:Tell HN: It's easier and faster to pirate an e-book, than...
by josephcsible on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:43PM
(#34188351)
Can you link to an example of such a contract? And besides, I thought the First Sale Doctrine meant that no matter what your contract said, once the book was sold that the copyright holder didn't have any say over that copy of it anymore.
Re:Tell HN: It's easier and faster to pirate an e-book, than...
by berniedurfee on Friday December 30, 2022 @08:46PM
(#34192532)
I’ve always wondered about this. In need to do some Googling, unless someone knows the answer.
Are libraries entitled to loan any book on the market? Do they need permission? Do they ever provide compensation?
Re:Tell HN: It's easier and faster to pirate an e-book, than...
by josephcsible on Saturday December 31, 2022 @01:50PM
(#34199431)
> Are libraries entitled to loan any book on the market? Do they need permission? Do they ever provide compensation?
My understanding is the answers are yes, no, and nothing besides the normal purchase price of the book.
Re:Tell HN: It's easier and faster to pirate an e-book, than...
by richardatlarge on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:07AM
(#34182664)
Amd no comparison was made to piracy