Re:DerDieDas.wtf: If you know the pain of learning the gende...
by ahartmetz on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @08:31PM
(#34168412)
That one is logical: the piece of cheese - it's a piece, not a cheese. The bottle of water - it's a bottle, not a water.
Re:DerDieDas.wtf: If you know the pain of learning the gende...
by sokoloff on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @08:38PM
(#34168461)
“Two waters, please.” will generally get you two servings of water in some kind of container.
Re:DerDieDas.wtf: If you know the pain of learning the gende...
by ahartmetz on Thursday December 29, 2022 @02:43AM
(#34170454)
Anyway, clearer example: wall paint is a paint, not a wall.
It is always this grammatical structure in German. Consider the alternative: weighing the "weight" of the parts of a compound word to figure out the grammatical gender. Lots of rules and exceptions! As it is, there is one very simple rule with AFAIK no exceptions.
German is difficult for sure, but the gender of compound words is a bad example to prove that.
And yeah, it's the equivalent to English prepositions, it's just lots of history and no logic.