Re:Do scientists really need a PhD?
by SilasX on Monday January 02, 2012 @12:05PM
(#3416497)
>My loose definition of science is that you observe, predict, experiment, and honestly report your results.
I would add one more thing: you become aware of others' efforts to do the same and build off of their work rather than "re-invent the wheel". (That doesn't mean you take it uncritically, just that you know what has been tried.)
That part is, AFAICT, what PhD programs most intensely focus on, i.e., make sure you understand the existing work well enough that you can build on it rather than just independently re-discover results in the field.
That part is also (usually) beyond the reach of five-year-olds.
Note: you can certainly still meet this requirement without an official PhD program, of course.
I would add one more thing: you become aware of others' efforts to do the same and build off of their work rather than "re-invent the wheel". (That doesn't mean you take it uncritically, just that you know what has been tried.)
That part is, AFAICT, what PhD programs most intensely focus on, i.e., make sure you understand the existing work well enough that you can build on it rather than just independently re-discover results in the field.
That part is also (usually) beyond the reach of five-year-olds.
Note: you can certainly still meet this requirement without an official PhD program, of course.