If you have no other gas appliances and generally reliable electric supply, I'd be inclined towards going with electric backup. That avoids the $10-15/month gas meter charge, which pays for a fair amount of the more costly electric heat. If you have other gas appliances and cheap [at least for now] natural gas supply, going with a natural gas backup allows you to use the cheaper source of heat for both backup and/or in case electricity rates go up substantially versus gas.
CO risk is minimal and you should have a line-powered CO meter in the mechanical room and some CO meter on each level of the house anyway.
Thank you for stating this. If your furnace requires electricity to run, you don’t need a battery-powered or battery backup CO meter. Unless you have a wood stove or light fires indoors when it gets chilly. Otherwise you’re just wasting batteries.
In winter the heat pump seems to have no issues meeting our heating needs albeit at quite a bit higher overall utility cost compared to our old gas furnace. In summer the heat pump is much more efficient than our old AC unit and our solar panels cover >100% of our usage from ~April-Oct.
Prior to installing the heat pump we did as much insulating as we could (mostly attic) and I think that was important for enabling the heat pump to keep up in the cold. The nature of the heating is lower level and continuous compared to the occasional blasting from a gas furnace, so you do want to prevent rapid leakage of heat from the house.
I am afraid that my overall utility expenses will go up drastically with a heat pump though. Can a heat pump even keep up with a house that loses heat like crazy out of the windows? I seem to get contradicting information from the salespeople, the internet, etc. if anyone has any anecdotal info it would be greatly appreciated
https://www.builditsolar.com/Projects/Conservation/bubblewra...
I started with my old Vermont home with minimal insulation, single pane metal frame windows that would ice up, and drafts everywhere. After our first winter, we had the local efficiency program recommend a contractor who came out and measured air exchange and identified the order of work. New windows, sealing attic, re-insulating attic. We got a considerable tax credit for the work, and the comfort improvement was astounding.
Just this last summer we made the jump to mini-split heat pumps. They are working well, but I doubt that would be the case without the air sealing. We keep them set at their lowest, 61F, and supplement with a wood stove in the living room, maybe burning 2 cords a year.
As an aside, this is our first winter, and our bill for December was 300 dollars, at $0.18/kWh. That's about 25% lower than our estimated oil charges last year for the same period. However, this year oil is ~$4.6, almost 50% higher, so that hedge against fossil fuel price is really paying off. Add in the AC comfort that is largely offset by our solar array, and they are a worthy investment (oh, and 0% financing).
None of this would be working without that critical investment in air sealing and insulation.
My concern is two-fold:
- my house is not well air sealed
- my house is not well insulated
So I worry that I'll need an extremely oversized heat pump in order to have enough capacacity for the coldest days.
I suppose having a backup heating source would prevent needing such a large unit. Plus it would provide some amount of redundancy of the heat pump were to fail in the winter.
The question then is, should I use electric backup heat, or stick with my existing gas connection? Electric is simpler and there's no exhaust fumes or CO risk to worry about, but gas is still cheaper here I think.