Re:The Rise of Archaeologists Anonymous
by smitty1e on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @09:47AM
(#34161440)
> There probably were queer Vikings
To state that there were zero instances of homosexuality in ancient Scandinavia is to go too far. How would one know?
But one might also ask:
- Why would one care?
- What difference would it make?
Re:The Rise of Archaeologists Anonymous
by sasattack on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @01:28PM
(#34164046)
It's valuable for young people to realize that Christian lies about the Eternity of heterosexuality Are in fact just lies. It actually is valuable for young people to know that there were people like them in history
Re:The Rise of Archaeologists Anonymous
by smitty1e on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @03:26PM
(#34165481)
Homosexuality is mentioned in the Bible. The nature of your argument is unclear.
Re:The Rise of Archaeologists Anonymous
by sasattack on Saturday December 31, 2022 @11:00AM
(#34197595)
Yes it's really positive about homosexuality and also there's no academic ambiguity about if it was really referring to homosexuality or if that's actually a translation artifact of the middle ages
> - Why would one care?
Why would one care about anything in the sciences?
> - What difference would it make?
As much difference as a lot of other form of pure scientific progress.
Perhaps more, in fact, depending on which political groups run with it.
Re:The Rise of Archaeologists Anonymous
by smitty1e on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @03:26PM
(#34165488)
Ah, "political groups".
Re:The Rise of Archaeologists Anonymous
by amadeuspagel on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:15PM
(#34166746)
The article does not blame archeologists for challenging common sense, it simply explains that the mainstream in archeology is far removed from common sense, because otherwise, a story about archeologists needing the protection of anonymity to discuss seemingly common sense ideas would not make any sense.
There probably were queer Vikings, borders probably were diffuse, conquest was complicated and probably didn’t affect the lives of most people most of the time. The archeology of that is really clear.
I think academias job is to find accurate answers and that requires challenging “common sense”. If that means asking if there were queer Vikings seems like the type of consensus defying questions worth asking!
This person sounds like a revanchist, looking to go back to a past that no longer exists.