News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hackers said to be planning to Launch Satellites to Comba... by rbanffy on Monday January 02, 2012 @07:38AM (#3415725)
I wonder whether it would be feasible to accelerate a balloon to LEO using an ion engine. It could use the hydrogen or helium in the balloon as reaction mass to go around pressure differential issues and build up horizontal speed as it goes up and loses lift.

Anyone wants to do the math? I'm a bit rusty.

Re:Hackers said to be planning to Launch Satellites to Comba... by leoedin on Monday January 02, 2012 @11:31AM (#3416372)
The ion engines used in existing spacecraft produces similar thrust to a piece of printer paper in your hand - the thrusts of the engines are measured in terms of milliNewtons. They are useful in deep space situations, where (due to nuclear reactors or abundant solar cells) you're power rich but propellant poor, and don't have to deal with aerodynamic drag. Over a long period of time, an ion engine can yield big velocities. With drag forces though, they'd simply have no effect on a floating balloon.

A balloon could present a method of getting a lightweight rocket to a very high altitude before engine firing, reducing the drag on the rocket and allowing the rocket engine to be designed just for the very low air pressure environment at those heights (rather than the compromise that modern ground-launched rockets have to make), but the size of the payload would be limited by the balloon size (with approximately 1kg/m^3 of helium, you'd need a lot of helium to lift a rocket of any size).

Re:Hackers said to be planning to Launch Satellites to Comba... by Symmetry on Monday January 02, 2012 @10:54AM (#3416241)
If the atmosphere is thick enough to support your balloon, its thick enough that something as low thrust as an ion engine basically won't be able to let you reach a meaningful velocity.
Re:Hackers said to be planning to Launch Satellites to Comba... by tocomment on Monday January 02, 2012 @09:58AM (#3416072)
I've had this smae idea many times! I really think its feasible but I can't do the math* either :-(

I've come to think there are many ways to reach orbit with our current levels of technology but it's just too expensive to do the R&D.

* I actually got suck on figuring out the helium required because everytime you add more helium it adds more weight which requires more helium and so on. It must need some kind of complex differential equation.

Re:Hackers said to be planning to Launch Satellites to Comba... by skytrail on Monday January 02, 2012 @10:18AM (#3416128)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation Delta-V = v_exhaust * ln( mass_initial / mass_final )
Re:Hackers said to be planning to Launch Satellites to Comba... by rbanffy on Monday January 02, 2012 @12:16PM (#3416533)
It's bit more complicated than that. The balloon lift will decrease with pressure, which will decrease with altitude but so will aerodynamic drag. Ion engines design for satellite operation also prioritize low reaction mass usage and I am not sure the low thrust is a hard limit or a design choice. The device could also use vertical thrust to compensate for the loss of lift and then gradually rotate until it reaches orbital speeds.

It's probably impossible with current propulsion technology, but it would be useful to have a number when it starts to be possible.

Re:Hackers said to be planning to Launch Satellites to Comba... by mikeash on Monday January 02, 2012 @01:28PM (#3416794)
Sadly, it's not feasible. For a great overview of why, see: http://groups.google.com/group/rec.arts.sf.science/browse_th...