There's nothing wrong with what you talk about in a perfect economic setting. I think humans reason beyond short term economics alone, and an act of graciousness during time of need will be reciprocated in the long run.
Reputationally, someone who gives away water during emergency, especially at tremendous cost to themselves get far better returns in the long run after the emergency. Similarly, people who take advantage of others during bad times are often punished or sanctioned later.
You have to understand that humans think very differently to Ferengi-style pure economics. Reputation matters. Back to the topic matter - Uber should consider hiring anthropologists in addition to their nuclear scientists when thinking about dynamic pricing.
And we have plenty of health and safety regs that prohibit, for example, ordering an employee to drive on an unsafe bridge, so that concern is rather a red herring.
The phrase "Price gouging" comes to mind. Even when dynamic pricing is available, as long as people are stuck, they will feel resentment.
Another example is when there are hurricanes or floods. Shops could charge "market pricing" for bottled water, but this only generates ill-will. What shops do is to ration the supplies so that all those who need bottled water get some.
The problem with cabs is you can't implement rationing. Furthermore, supply is always going to be tight even if all the limousines came out in full force. It is one of those once-a-year spike in demand.
The airline industry solves this problem by offering advance bookings. The benefits of advance booking is that it incorporates some kind of price signal so that people can decide whether they wish to travel or not. However, it will take considerable cultural change for people to modify their discretionary going-out based on fares alone.