1pw really doesn't play nice with yubikeys. LP has no issues (i think it doesn't use WebAuth, which 1P does). 1P UI is nicer. LP is a bit clunky. Not being able to add notes/docs to 1P in the extension kinda stinks ... why can't they just open the vault like LP does. They seem to be very similar: they both crap all over login forms! I like the secret key thing now: it basically forces people to have big passwords. But I find it annoying because my passphrase is enormous to begin with, I don't want to have to fuss with managing another key. I think they are neck-and-neck from my security posture view.