News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:60beat iPad Gaming Accessory Could Be The iOS Missing Link by brudgers on Sunday January 01, 2012 @04:27PM (#3413897)
>"a unique user interface of its own."

For a game developer, this might tend to limit the desirability of porting existing games to the market or even developing games for it.

A lot of time and thought went into the dual stick interface.

Re:60beat iPad Gaming Accessory Could Be The iOS Missing Link by ja2ke on Sunday January 01, 2012 @05:15PM (#3413992)
I don't think the unique input methods brought on by a multitouch glass display has limited the desirability to game developers... 3-4 years ago that could have been a concern, but the huge iOS games market has shown that to not be the case. We're getting unique, tremendously well-selling experiences on touch/mobile devices with great regularity. Major publishers and indies are churning out games for these devices, all without a keyboard, mouse, or controller required to play.

It's true that you can't play every genre of game on an iPad, but it's also been true for years that not every genre of PC game would play well on a mainline TV console (traditional adventure games, strategy games, and anything with a lot of diverse/unique user input or complex underlying systems tends to fail on a 360 controller/living room couch situation), and not every GameBoy/DS game would work well there either.

That aside, personally as a gamer I'm glad that there are game systems out there with nearly mutually exclusive input methods, because it prevents lazy ports, and lazy ports generally, basically, suck to play.

Re:60beat iPad Gaming Accessory Could Be The iOS Missing Link by extension on Sunday January 01, 2012 @05:14PM (#3413990)
As a player, I don't want to see existing joystick games ported to iOS. I can already play those games in their existing form, and the virtual joystick experience, for all the thought that has been put into it, still sucks.

What I want to see on iOS are games that fit naturally into the touch interface, which can be existing games that just adapt well, or entirely new concepts.

What makes a touch interface work, I think, is directly manipulating what you see. Control schemes that rely on "body extension", like a joystick or directional pad, rarely translate well.