News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by edw519 on Thursday October 23, 2008 @12:18PM (#341315)
FWIW, my personal experince...

I have interviewed over 2500 programmer applicants, all having passed a "resume screening". I terminated 50% of the interviews before reaching the coding test because I knew by then that it would be a waste of time. Of the other 50%, 90% couldn't pass the simple coding test. I ended up hiring or referring less than 100.

Anyone else have similar experience with these percentages?

Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by dcminter on Thursday October 23, 2008 @06:25PM (#341758)
I rather like Joel Spolsky's observation that when one is hiring one is not selecting from the population of programmers, but rather from the population of programmers without jobs. A very different prospect.
Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by aneesh on Thursday October 23, 2008 @11:33PM (#342015)
Not necessarily. Often the best candidates are the ones you have to tempt out of their current position.
Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by pmjordan on Thursday October 23, 2008 @02:06PM (#341463)
My sample size is much smaller, (I quit a few months after I started getting involved with hiring at my last job) but they sound about right.

It's pretty amazing how easy it is to get a degree in compsci or game development and have no programming competence whatsoever. What amazed me too was the astounding quantity of terrible CVs, even among people who supposedly have a substantial amount of experience. I used to laugh at articles telling you to spell check your application and give other, seemingly extremely basic advice, but I swear about 80-90% of applications have glaring spelling, grammar and semantic mistakes and no discernible logical structure. Come on, how hard is it to assemble a chronological list of things you've done?

Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by bigthboy on Thursday October 23, 2008 @04:18PM (#341638)
Sometimes those mistakes don't come from competency of the program writer but rather the translator...

"All your base are belong to us!"

Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by pmjordan on Friday October 24, 2008 @02:50AM (#342153)
Oh, don't worry - I wasn't complaining about immigrants. I'm talking about people who (according to their CV, and by the sound of their name) had spent all their life in the UK.
Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by gaius on Friday October 24, 2008 @05:12AM (#342211)
One thing you need to watch out for is recruiters "reformatting" people's CVs, possibly without their knowledge, into their "house style". One candidate I interviewed happened to bring an original copy of his CV with him, it was quite radically different to what I had in my hands.
Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by biohacker42 on Thursday October 23, 2008 @02:42PM (#341526)
Could it be good programmers are worse resume writers?

Perhaps if you had a different way of pre-screening candidates, something besides resumes.

Perhaps even if the pre-screening itself took much more time then scanning a resume - overall it might end up saving time?

Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by Wesha on Thursday October 23, 2008 @11:55PM (#342046)
> Could it be good programmers are worse resume writers?

Judging by myself: FSCKING YES!!!

The only thing I hate more than resume writing is Java,

This freaking "resume screening" selects best resume writers, not best programmers.

Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by fendale on Friday October 24, 2008 @09:07AM (#342312)
Oh come on - writing a resume is not that hard! Its two pages max, and while I agree its the most tedious undesirable task in the world, 3 or 4 hours spent on it will sort it once and for all. Then all you have to do is update it every 3 - 6 months for 30 minutes and it will always be ready to use.

Its basically just a bunch of buzz words on the skills you have, and a paragraph about your last few positions/roles.

Re:The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview) by staunch on Thursday October 23, 2008 @02:34PM (#341514)
I never call people in for interviews without a phone screening. It's a waste of their time and mine.