William Patry, a famous copyright expert who worked for Google, actually put out an entire book of ideas about how to fix copyright not very long ago (it's even named "How to Fix Copyright"). I guess that not many people around here have noticed it though.
Of course creative people should be compensated for their work. Therefore we need ways for consumers to pay for what they consumed on a voluntary basis. Flattr and Kachingle come to my mind. Louis CK showed that people are willing to pay (even though he did not release under a CC license).
Giving away a startup idea for free: Start a clearing house system based on stripe, where people can pay artists and authors for their work. Pay for the the business expenses with a marginal fee, maybe 10-15% that is very clearly and transparently communicated to the public.
I would rather pay 10$ for an ebook|film|album where 9$ reach the artist, than buy something DRM crippled for 15$ where only 2$ reach the artist. Even more so, if it is only marginally less convenient to pay than to simply download from TPB.
So yes, the system is fundamentally broken, but it is in our hands to build something better.