News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Unpopular Opinion: Brown was acting like a jerk

And Musk just called him out on it. Nobody should talk to anybody, not a partner, not a colleague, not an intern, in the way Brown did "ask" Musk "questions". He wanted to provoke an emotional reaction from him that way, ending his totally innocent questions in "C'mon buddy!".

Apparently there had been an architecture diagram (that Hotz had shown) outlining the mammoth architecture of twitter. Just naming random items from that diagram would not have helped anyone, except Brown's ego. IMO, that's why there was laughter, because Browns questions were not only confrontational, provocative and manipulative, but also pointless.

I'm pretty sure that everybody participating in the discussion was aware how refactoring or rewriting in such a big product works and what the problems are. Musk (and it doesn't matter if it was him directly or people working for him) does have an idea how to refactor; he successfully refactored the way we had been building rockets for decades.

You can hear that he wanted to start answering the part of Brown's questions that actually made sense and weren't solely provocation (skeleton rewrite vs back to drawing board), when you hear the 'click' when Musk realized that all that Brown wanted to do was to put him on the spot. That's when he correctly identified him as a jackass.

Brown does sound like one of those manipulative/toxic workplace people you should stay clear of.

Everybody just latches on to Musk, because they're not thinking neutrally, they hate him, for whatever amalgamation of reasons, assume he is a jackass and idiot - and then find their proof for it.

( 7 comments | on HN )
Re:Unpopular Opinion: Brown was acting like a jerk by syzarian on Sunday December 25, 2022 @09:59AM (#34127747)
I think you have it backwards in your last paragraph. Five years ago Elon Musk had a lot of goodwill and was highly thought of by lots of people. Through his actions as a boss and through his public statements he’s shown himself to be a jackass. There is a cadre of supporters who forgive or overlook the overwhelming evidence of his jackassery. Perhaps you should consider the possibility that you are among this cadre of supporters.

I don’t know who Brown is and it’s quite possible he/she too is a jackass but that doesn’t detract from the fact that Elon Musk is a shitty person.

Re:Unpopular Opinion: Brown was acting like a jerk by residualmind on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:05PM (#34130044)
you might want to try to realize that my post was not directed at you but at people who think differently, or if not, at least try to respond to the points I'm making.

if you don't know who Ian Brown is - who I'm talking about here - how can you have a qualified response to what i said?

Re:Unpopular Opinion: Brown was acting like a jerk by syzarian on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:23PM (#34130277)
Everybody just latches on to Musk, because they're not thinking neutrally, they hate him, for whatever amalgamation of reasons, assume he is a jackass and idiot - and then find their proof for it.

I specifically said that I was responding to this paragraph. This paragraph appears to be a general statement that is not limited in scope to only be about Brown.

Re:Unpopular Opinion: Brown was acting like a jerk by residualmind on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:30PM (#34130337)
ok, sorry, I'm not having a great day,i apologize.
Re:Unpopular Opinion: Brown was acting like a jerk by lordkrandel on Sunday December 25, 2022 @10:24AM (#34127978)
No. Every boss who says "total rewrite" deserves the correspective of a punch in the face. It's like saying: what you engineers have done and I paid 44 billion dollars for, is worth nothing at all. It's worse than s* because at least that can be used at fuel. Musk is the jerk 100%
Re:Unpopular Opinion: Brown was acting like a jerk by residualmind on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:55PM (#34129953)
i dunno.. as an engineer, with every project i've jumped into, among of the first ideas to tackle code rot was usually a total rewrite of some key parts, agreed upon by all the other external engineers.. is it usually a good/practical idea? probably not, but if you have a huge piece of organically grown garbage, taking few steps back and entertaining the thought "how would we do it now, knowing what we know now (and what all these people have learned the hard way)", does not sound like the worst of ideas.
Re:Unpopular Opinion: Brown was acting like a jerk by residualmind on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:02PM (#34130018)
you're familiar with tech debt, right? what if a board of engineers and not your supervillain says a rewrite is one of the things we can try to breathe some life into this