Re:Driving has lost its cool for young Americans
by MichaelSalib on Saturday December 31, 2011 @04:06PM
(#3411843)
Would Amtrak be cost effective if Congress didn't force it to run lots of unprofitable routes that it was desperately trying to shed? This is a fun game! Congress forces Amtrak to lose money and then lambastes it for not being profitable.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Driving has lost its cool for young Americans
by tptacek on Saturday December 31, 2011 @04:09PM
(#3411852)
Who are you arguing with? Me? I like the Acela, and wish we had one running STL->Chi->Memphis. I could care less about the availability of a 2-day sleeper car route from Chicago to the west coast.
Re:Driving has lost its cool for young Americans
by MichaelSalib on Saturday December 31, 2011 @04:19PM
(#3411883)
I'm not arguing with anyone. I just don't think Congressman "have a valid point regarding Amtrak" when they complain about a problem they're largely responsible for. Don't you agree? Or do you think they do "have a valid point regarding Amtrak"?
Re:Driving has lost its cool for young Americans
by tptacek on Saturday December 31, 2011 @04:32PM
(#3411924)
I think they have a valid point regarding Amtrak.
I think they have a valid point even if you narrow the whole thing down to the Acela. I do not have a hard time believing that the Northeast Rail Corridor is less cost-effective than air.
I'm pretty sure they have a valid point when you consider Amtrak nationwide.
I do not think that their point is dispositive. The Acela can be inefficient and still worth retaining and (as I've argued elsewhere here) extended.
But I object to the notion that they have no valid argument at all.