Re:Atari abuses copyright to kick competitors out of the iOS...
by extension on Saturday December 31, 2011 @02:38PM
(#3411625)
Yep. And in the case of Battlezone, a game that is about its appearance, I would argue that the expression can't be separated from the abstract idea. But I doubt we'll ever see a court's opinion on that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Atari abuses copyright to kick competitors out of the iOS...
by biot on Saturday December 31, 2011 @03:30PM
(#3411749)
To me, the abstract idea is a 3D wireframe world where you accumulate points and avoid being shot by wireframe enemies, much in the same way that the Munchkin ruling says:
Other games, such as "Rally-X" (described in Dirkschneider)
and North American's own "Take the Money and Run," illustrate
different ways in which a basic maze-chase game can be expressed.
The idea could still have been a 3D wireframe world where things try and shoot you, but it didn't have to be tanks. Atari's own Star Wars: Empire Strikes Back from 1985 shows how the idea can have a radically different expression.