The trick in addressing technology development is to choose the right level of generalization. At some point, you're going to be communicating in leaky abstractions no matter what you say. My overall critique of the article was that the few paragraphs the author provided wasn't deep enough and led to a false impression, not that remote work is somehow unworkable. I could easily post some HN click-bait like "SOPA is the Devil!" and watch the votes climb. What would be tough to do -- and much more useful -- is to provide some kind of analysis where both sides were presented, along with some possible solutions. The first kind of article is a waste of my Saturday morning. The second kind gets me to thinking some. I like that a lot better.
Once there is a basic plan in place, face time (or phone/IM) are fine to flesh out smaller issues, Q&A, etc.
Apparently someone did. The express purpose of the Kernel Developers Summit is to work out problems that couldn't be resolved online.
An equivalent would be someone working 9 to 5 in an office and doing two days of "work from home" in a year.
Open source projects generally have no deadlines. It's always a work in progress. So, team "magic" isn't really necessary.
The magic doesn't happen when nobody has met each other and communication is limited to telephone, email, and IM."
Someone should tell the Linux Kernel (and other Open Source dev, where a lot of terrific "as magic as it can get" sw dev happens) guys.
No, I am not saying that OS dev is the same as commercial dev, or even that what you are saying is essentially wrong.
I am just challenging the absolute nature of "The magic doesn't happen when nobody has met each other and communication is limited to telephone, email, and IM." Plenty of "magic" does happen every day when people who know each other only by their irc handles or email ids work together on a codebase.
Whether such activity can be harnessed to help a commercial dev effort is certainly debatable (and there are many good points on either side of the issuel), but the idea of confining "magic" in software dev to only dev teams working in the same room is somewhat dubious (imho, ymmv etc).
That said, time to party here in Bangalore. Happy New Year, everyone!